Peer Review

[AdrianUofT]

https://github.com/apang00/mp/blob/825581894445261ee2491a6033ad5730cbf62488/paper/paper.qmd#L8

What link?

https://github.com/apang00/mp/blob/825581894445261ee2491a6033ad5730cbf62488/README.md?plain=1#L1

"Starter Folder"

https://github.com/apang00/mp/blob/main/paper/datasheet_template.pdf https://github.com/apang00/mp/blob/main/paper/datasheet_template.qmd

What are these files for?

https://github.com/apang00/mp/blob/main/other/llm/usage.txt

So you guys used LLMs the same way that was shown in the default starter folder

https://github.com/apang00/mp/blob/825581894445261ee2491a6033ad5730cbf62488/paper/paper.qmd#L38

????

"Figure 1: Figure 1"

https://github.com/apang00/mp/blob/825581894445261ee2491a6033ad5730cbf62488/paper/paper.qmd#L52

????

Ok? You should definitely cross-reference subsections I think

https://github.com/apang00/mp/blob/825581894445261ee2491a6033ad5730cbf62488/paper/paper.qmd#L58-L68

Your data is about penguins?

At least talk about it.

https://github.com/apang00/mp/blob/825581894445261ee2491a6033ad5730cbf62488/paper/paper.qmd#L44

Do you even know how to cite properly with your references file???

https://github.com/apang00/mp/blob/825581894445261ee2491a6033ad5730cbf62488/paper/paper.qmd#L107-L125

????

Did you even complete anything past your introduction?

https://github.com/apang00/mp/blob/825581894445261ee2491a6033ad5730cbf62488/paper/paper.qmd#L88-L95

Your discussion is empty I think

https://github.com/apang00/mp/blob/825581894445261ee2491a6033ad5730cbf62488/paper/paper.qmd#L72-L76

What model are you even trying to incorporate?

https://github.com/apang00/mp/blob/825581894445261ee2491a6033ad5730cbf62488/paper/paper.qmd#L80-L82

Your "summarized results" don't even load or reference anything

https://github.com/apang00/mp/blob/825581894445261ee2491a6033ad5730cbf62488/paper/paper.qmd#L48

????

"enpolicy one year later"

https://chat.openai.com/g/g-YLjkOEBIQ-telling-stories-with-data

You can ask it how to cite with quatro

You can also ask it about the task you are given for this paper

Where is your SSRP?

https://github.com/apang00/mp/blob/825581894445261ee2491a6033ad5730cbf62488/README.md?plain=1#L5

Your paper is associated with Telling Stories with Data ?

https://tellingstorieswithdata.com/23-assessment.html#rubric-1

You should check out this resource. It will help a lot for your paper.

https://github.com/apang00/mp/blob/main/scripts/00-simulate_data.R https://github.com/apang00/mp/blob/main/scripts/01-download_data.R https://github.com/apang00/mp/blob/main/scripts/02-data_cleaning.R https://github.com/apang00/mp/blob/main/scripts/03-test_data.R https://github.com/apang00/mp/blob/main/scripts/04-model.R https://github.com/apang00/mp/blob/main/scripts/99-replications.R https://github.com/apang00/mp/blob/main/other/literature/Alexander-ProjectOfStateLevel.pdf https://github.com/apang00/mp/tree/main/models

You're supposed to update these I think

What is the point of these files?

You don't even have simulated data

You don't have tests for the simulated data

You don't have tests for your actual data

Are you even cleaning your data?

Did you even source your data properly?

Where is the citation for the libraries you used?

https://github.com/apang00/mp/tree/main/other/sketches

Don't think these sketches are representative of your data set

What is "mp"?

Your repo name is terrible

I look through this entire repo and I still have no idea what you're trying to talk about in your paper

What paper are you even trying to replicate?