apohl79 / audiogridder

DSP servers using general purpose computers and networks
https://audiogridder.com
MIT License
738 stars 77 forks source link

AudioGridderPluginTray immediately terminates - first install on M1 macbook air #1200

Closed andrasp closed 1 year ago

andrasp commented 1 year ago

This is my first time trying AudioGridder. My host system is a Windows 10 PC, while my client system running the DAW is an M1 Macbook Air.

What works

I installed the latest 1.2 version of the server on the Windows 10 PC without any issues. Working great and finding all of my plugins there.

What doesn't work

On the client system (M1 Macbook Air) I used brew install audiogridder-plugin to install the 1.2 version of the plugin package. I tried to launch AudioGridderPluginTray, but the process terminates very quickly. I see the icon for it in the menu bar but then it vanishes almost as fast as it appeared. Confirmed with activity monitor that the process indeed terminates:

Screen Shot 2023-04-10 at 4 31 43 PM

I started looking for logs to see if I can understand what might be going on.

Screen Shot 2023-04-10 at 4 30 12 PM

This is the only log output I get for Tray. There are no diagnostic reports in either /Library/Logs/DiagnosticReports or in ~/Library/Logs/DiagnosticReports. Similarly nothing in CrashReporter in either the root or user path.

Screen Shot 2023-04-10 at 4 29 29 PM

I see the VST files installed under the root path:

Screen Shot 2023-04-10 at 4 27 58 PM

However, when starting up my DAW (Studio One) it cannot load them, stating they crash:

Screen Shot 2023-04-10 at 4 42 31 PM

I tried installing the 1.1 version, same result. I tried using pkg directly instead of going through homebrew, same result. As it stands it looks dead on arrival.

Obligatory mention: yes, I was only using the M1 built options from the download page (arm64).

Could someone help me understand what I am doing wrong, or is this a bug?

apohl79 commented 1 year ago

first of all, you would not run the tray app manually. it is started once you load a plugin into your daw and it quits automatically, once no plugin is loaded.

if s1 does not load AG it might be an issue with the CPU architecture. I have brew set to install the universal build. not sure if s1 has issues with that. you could head over to the homepage and get the arm only build and try that.

also you might want to try the vst3 or audiounit versions.

andrasp commented 1 year ago

@apohl79 Thank you for clearing that up regarding the tray app!

It turns out I was using the correct versions of the packages, but Studio One version 3 cannot load them for some reason on an M1 macbook air. I installed the demo version of Studio One version 6 which was able to load everything without any issue. It looks like I'm just out of luck with Studio One version 3.

Since this doesn't look to be an AudioGridder issue I am resolving this.

apohl79 commented 1 year ago

is s1 version 3 arm native or is it an intel build that runs under rosetta? in that case you need the x86 build of AG.

andrasp commented 1 year ago

You are correct. Studio one version 3 is not native M1 compatible. It looks like version 5.4 is the first one with native support. Thank you!