aras-p / ClangBuildAnalyzer

Clang build analysis tool using -ftime-trace
The Unlicense
969 stars 60 forks source link

-Wformat warnings on gcc 9.3.0 #61

Closed YarikTH closed 3 years ago

YarikTH commented 3 years ago

When I compiled the latest release (v1.2.0) I got some interesting warnings:

/opt/Workspace/ClangBuildAnalyzer/src/BuildEvents.cpp:55:26: warning: format ‘%i’ expects argument of type ‘int’, but argument 3 has type ‘BuildEventType’ [-Wformat=]
   55 |         printf("%4zi: t=%i t1=%7llu t2=%7llu par=%4i ch=%4zi det=%s\n", i, event.type, event.ts, event.ts+event.dur, event.parent.idx, event.children.size(), std::string(names[event.detailIndex].substr(0,130)).c_str());
      |                         ~^                                                 ~~~~~~~~~~
      |                          |                                                       |
      |                          int                                                     BuildEventType
/opt/Workspace/ClangBuildAnalyzer/src/BuildEvents.cpp:55:35: warning: format ‘%llu’ expects argument of type ‘long long unsigned int’, but argument 4 has type ‘int64_t’ {aka ‘long int’} [-Wformat=]
   55 |         printf("%4zi: t=%i t1=%7llu t2=%7llu par=%4i ch=%4zi det=%s\n", i, event.type, event.ts, event.ts+event.dur, event.parent.idx, event.children.size(), std::string(names[event.detailIndex].substr(0,130)).c_str());
      |                               ~~~~^                                                    ~~~~~~~~
      |                                   |                                                          |
      |                                   long long unsigned int                                     int64_t {aka long int}
      |                               %7lu
/opt/Workspace/ClangBuildAnalyzer/src/BuildEvents.cpp:55:44: warning: format ‘%llu’ expects argument of type ‘long long unsigned int’, but argument 5 has type ‘long int’ [-Wformat=]
   55 |         printf("%4zi: t=%i t1=%7llu t2=%7llu par=%4i ch=%4zi det=%s\n", i, event.type, event.ts, event.ts+event.dur, event.parent.idx, event.children.size(), std::string(names[event.detailIndex].substr(0,130)).c_str());
      |                                        ~~~~^                                                     ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
      |                                            |                                                             |
      |                                            long long unsigned int                                        long int
      |                                        %7lu

How about using "{fmt}" for such formatted output? It might be overhead though to add another external library just for it. At least warnings can be fixed if instead of inlining all args, we declare constants for all of them with types that was declared in prrintf:

        const auto eventType = static_cast<int>(event.type); // %i
        const auto t1 = static_cast<long long unsigned int>(event.ts); // %7llu
        const auto t2 = static_cast<long long unsigned int>(event.ts+event.dur); // %7llu
        const auto par = static_cast<int>(event.parent.idx); // %4i
        const auto ch = static_cast<size_t>(event.children.size());
        const auto det = std::string(names[event.detailIndex].substr(0,130)); // %s
        printf("%4zi: t=%i t1=%7llu t2=%7llu par=%4i ch=%4zi det=%s\n", i, eventType, t1, t2, par, ch, det.c_str());
YarikTH commented 3 years ago

It was an error to report warnings not from master. Found ca8796eb (fix conversion warnings) where it kind of fixed.