search

arc42 / arc42.org-site

(jekyll-based) website for arc42.org - the template for communicating software architectures.
https://arc42.org
MIT License
6 stars 19 forks source link

Example for quality scenarios are not really quality scenarios #43

Closed ewolff closed 2 years ago

ewolff commented 2 years ago

https://docs.arc42.org/examples/quality-htmlsc-2/ and https://docs.arc42.org/examples/quality-tpu-1/ are not really quality scenarios. As https://github.com/arc42/quality-requirements/ points out, there should be a business goal, an event, a reaction, and a metric for each quality scenario. Usually none of these is present. This is misleading. Until fixed I suggest to remove these examples. They do more harm than good.

gernotstarke commented 2 years ago

thanx Eberhard, it seems I'm more of a pragmatic than you are... and some people even told me these examples helped. In case you have better examples, I'd be most grateful for any PR (with the side effect that you'd become an arc42 contributor :-)

ewolff commented 2 years ago

Thanks for clarifying.