search

ardc-fair-checklist / ardc-fair-checklist.github.io

Self-assessment checklist for FAIR software
https://fairsoftwarechecklist.net
Apache License 2.0
1 stars 1 forks source link

User feedback #49

Open jspaaks opened 1 year ago

jspaaks commented 1 year ago

Notes from review session Nov 30, 2022

code state: https://github.com/ardc-fair-checklist/ssg/tree/ce660569c3bbedaf3f5a508113bf460f02e60b86

software checklist filled out for https://github.comCLARIAH/grlc

Numbers below are question numbers:

  1.  
  2. phrasing is a bit confusing, maybe explain granularity and component
  3.  
  4.  
  5.  
  6. if having it in Zenodo is good enough, maybe you don't need to ask or you can recommend an answer already. Also, the question says "indexable" but maybe it should be "indexed"?
  7.  
  8.  
  9. is my protocol http/https (for a repo on GitHub with deposition on Zenodo)? and if so, what does that mean
  10. strictly speaking no answers are truthful
  11.  
  12. unsure, phrasing too complicated
  13.  
  14. maybe add docker image, singularity, etc to last answer; Also consider allowing checking multiple items
  15.  
  16. "comprehensively" what does it mean?
  17. For a Python package with dependencies in a requirements.txt with version ranges for some packages, which option should I put? Also, consider adding "Other (please explain)" field.
  18.