Yun network sketch upload and SSH key

[aboudou]

Hello,

I've set up my Arduino Yun to only accept SSH logins with private key, and on a different port than 22. It seems Arduino IDE 1.5.4 does not allow these settings when uploading sketches through networked port.

I get the following error messages :

• When SSH daemon does not listen on port 22

processing.app.debug.RunnerException at cc.arduino.packages.uploaders.SSHUploader.uploadUsingPreferences(SSHUploader.java:103) at processing.app.Sketch.upload(Sketch.java:1692) at processing.app.Sketch.exportApplet(Sketch.java:1605) at processing.app.Sketch.exportApplet(Sketch.java:1577) at processing.app.Editor$DefaultExportHandler.run(Editor.java:2397) at java.lang.Thread.run(Thread.java:680) Caused by: com.jcraft.jsch.JSchException: java.net.ConnectException: Connection refused at com.jcraft.jsch.Util.createSocket(Util.java:389) at com.jcraft.jsch.Session.connect(Session.java:215) at cc.arduino.packages.uploaders.SSHUploader.uploadUsingPreferences(SSHUploader.java:91) ... 5 more

• When SSH daemon listen on port 22 but only allows private / public key auth

processing.app.debug.RunnerException at cc.arduino.packages.uploaders.SSHUploader.uploadUsingPreferences(SSHUploader.java:103) at processing.app.Sketch.upload(Sketch.java:1692) at processing.app.Sketch.exportApplet(Sketch.java:1605) at processing.app.Sketch.exportApplet(Sketch.java:1577) at processing.app.Editor$DefaultExportHandler.run(Editor.java:2397) at java.lang.Thread.run(Thread.java:680) Caused by: com.jcraft.jsch.JSchException: Auth fail at com.jcraft.jsch.Session.connect(Session.java:512) at cc.arduino.packages.uploaders.SSHUploader.uploadUsingPreferences(SSHUploader.java:91) ... 5 more

Arduino IDE should be able to let user changes SSH settings, or be able to use .ssh/config file.

Regards

[ffissore]

@aboudou I confirm the IDE only works with password authentication and uses port 22. Just to set up a test environment, which OS are you using?

[aboudou]

Hi,

I'm using OS X 10.8.5.

[ffissore]

I've just pushed d5bd7d13a72ea6a027a9df50cf7ec2756aba0bfe with a preliminary support for openssh config file and I would like you to test it. You can download a mac build here.

It expects config file to be located at USER_HOME/.ssh/config Example entry:

Host Arduino.local
       #optional
       IdentityFile ~/.ssh/id_rsa
       #mandatory if using IdentityFile
       StrictHostKeyChecking no
       #optional
       User root
       #optional
       Port 50022

Most important is the hostname: if your yun is named mysuperyun entry must be Host mysuperyun.local

[aboudou]

Hi,

I've just tried this build of Arduino IDE, and it's still not working:

When I try to upload the sketch, the IDE is asking my arduino board password (I don't know if it's user's password, or private key password, but none of them work).

My Arduino board name is "malheur", and my ~/.ssh/config file contains the following entries:

Host malheur User root port 22 StrictHostKeyChecking no identityFile ~/.ssh/yun

Host malheur.local User root port 22 StrictHostKeyChecking no identityFile ~/.ssh/yun

[ffissore]

Can you remove the first entry and retry? How does the IDE print the hostname? Is it malheur, all lowercase?

[aboudou]

With only the second entry, it keeps asking me for password.

And the port in Arduino IDE is "malheur at 192.168.xxx.yyy (Arduino Yun)"

[aboudou]

I've just checked : it's still trying to connect without using ~/.ssh/config file :

• I re-enabled password authentication, and I could upload sketch to Yun => private key is not used to authenticate
• Then I change port param into config file to a bad value, and this time again I could upload sketch to Yun => config file is not used.

[ffissore]

I've tested it with a mac (10.6) and it works. There is some difference in the config files we are missing. Can we compare them?

My /etc/config/dropbear is

config dropbear
    option PasswordAuth 'off'
    option RootPasswordAuth 'off'
    option Port         '50022'
#   option BannerFile   '/etc/banner'

My /Users/federico/.ssh/config is

Host Arduino.local
       IdentityFile /Users/federico/.ssh/id_rsa
       StrictHostKeyChecking no
       User root
       Port 50022

Board name is Arduino

I succeed in logging in with plain ssh without being prompted for a password. When I upload a sketch and I'm asked for the password, the pass phrase is the one

[aboudou]

Hi.

My dropbear config file :

config dropbear option Port '22' option PasswordAuth 'off' option RootPasswordAuth 'off'

My ssh config file (only the yun section)

Host malheur.local User root port 22 StrictHostKeyChecking no identityFile ~/.ssh/yun

Plain ssh login :

aboudou@skuld# ssh malheur.local Warning: Permanently added 'malheur.local' (RSA) to the list of known hosts.

BusyBox v1.19.4 (2013-08-07 16:16:02 CEST) built-in shell (ash) Enter 'help' for a list of built-in commands.

root@malheur:~#

[aboudou]

And I've just find the problem :

CLI ssh is not case sensitive for ssh config option names, Arduino IDE is :+1:

Works with CLI ssh but not with Arduino IDE : port 22 identityFile ~/.ssh/yun

Works with both CLI ssh and Arduino IDE

Port 22 IdentityFile ~/.ssh/yun

[ffissore]

Ah ok! Yes, jsch (the pure java ssh client we use) looks up keys in a case-sensitive manner. Are you then fine with this? Would you like some more time to test it? In the meanwhile, I've uploaded another build that fixes a small bug. https://docs.google.com/file/d/0B25ol7x7AsJRNW1vUEtEVHV1WGc/edit?usp=sharing

[aboudou]

I'm fine with the case sensitive behavior. I just had to know it :)

About the new build, it works without issue.

Thanks for your help :)

[noblepepper]

I still have strange behavior after configuring this. ssh logins through a terminal work fine with no password. The first time I upload a sketch after starting the IDE a dialog asks me to "Type board password to upload a new sketch", if I click the upload button the sketch uploads with no problems without entering a password. The dialog doesn't pop up when uploading after this unless I close all IDE windows. If I shut the IDE down completely and restart it I get the dialog the first time I upload.

Details: Host system is Ubuntu 13.04 64 bit IDE is nightly build for Linux 64 bit downloaded on November 2, 2013 Log on Yun shows Child connection, Pubkey auth and exit on each upload regardless of whether dialog pops up.

On host-

~/.ssh/config:
Host elbonoYun.local
       #optional
       IdentityFile ~/.ssh/id_rsa
       #mandatory if using IdentityFile
       StrictHostKeyChecking no
       #optional
       User root
       #optional
       Port 22

On Yun-

/etc/config/dropbear:
config dropbear
    option PasswordAuth 'off'
    option RootPasswordAuth 'off'
    option Port         '22'
 #  option BannerFile   '/etc/banner'

I generally leave password auth on, changed it to off since that is what you use above, doesn't make any difference.

For more information or suggestions just let me know.

Thanks, Noble

[ffissore]

If your local (private) key is protected by a pass phrase, the IDE will ask for it the first time you upload. SSH keys are usually "pass phrase protected".

[noblepepper]

I didn't use a pass phrase, ran ssh-keygen -t rsa and hit enter three times. My original forum post was with a dsa key but I switched to rsa since you and aboudou were using them here in case it made any difference. I'm just using this key for the Yun so I'm not super paranoid about how secure it is.

Maybe the IDE is asking for it even though it is not needed? If so it figures out it doesn't need it after it asks.

When I started playing with this I was entering my Yun's root password in the dialog and then noticed the log entries that indicated it was using the key to log in and found out it would work with no entry. I definitely didn't use that password for the pass phrase. I just ran the IDE again and put "how now brown cow" in the password dialog and it uploaded fine.

This isn't a critical issue, clicking OK isn't that big a deal, it is just one of those things that "ain't right"

[ffissore]

Got that. I'll fix it

[ffissore]

1.5.5 does not contain this latest fix. Moving issue to 1.5.6

[ffissore]

Moved to 1.5.7: still missing support to ssh keys without passphrase