search

arendst / Tasmota

Alternative firmware for ESP8266 and ESP32 based devices with easy configuration using webUI, OTA updates, automation using timers or rules, expandability and entirely local control over MQTT, HTTP, Serial or KNX. Full documentation at
https://tasmota.github.io/docs
GNU General Public License v3.0
22.04k stars 4.78k forks source link

After Mqtt "cmnd" command missing data in "state" acknowledgement. #1162

Closed pcopa closed 6 years ago

pcopa commented 6 years ago

Has anyone observed this?

After OTA updating my modules to 5,9.0b I noticed that the module was behaving different. It seems that the prefix "oh/" that I added to the mqtt conf "oh/%prefix%/%topic%/" is not being transmitted in the "stat" acknowledgement anymore. When pushing the button on the module it is transmitted! See Below

image

image

ionciubotaru commented 6 years ago

Set FullTopic %prefix%/%topic%/ If the problem still persist check the value of prefix

user34756361233 commented 6 years ago

same problem here:

user_config.h #define MQTT_FULLTOPIC "home/esp8266/tasmota/%topic%/" #define SUB_PREFIX "cmnd"
#define PUB_PREFIX "stat"
#define PUB_PREFIX2 "tele"

part of result: "OK" 10:43:05 MQT: home/esp8266/tasmota/sonoff_077697/cmnd/POWER = 10:43:05 MQT: home/esp8266/tasmota/sonoff_077697/INFO1 = {"Module":"Sonoff Basic", "Version":"5.9.1", "FallbackTopic":"sonoff_077697", "GroupTopic":"sonoffs"} "NOT OK" 10:56:02 RSL: Received Topic home/esp8266/tasmota/sonoff_077697/cmnd/Status, Data Size 1, Data 0 10:56:02 RSL: Group 0, Index 1, Command STATUS, Data 0 10:57:53 MQT: stat/sonoff_077697/STATUS = {"Status":{"Module":1, "FriendlyName":"sonoff_077697 Printer/Lader Stud", "Topic":"sonoff_077697", "ButtonTopic":"0", "Power":1, "PowerOnState":3, "LedState":1, "SaveData":1, "SaveState":1, "ButtonRetain":0, "PowerRetain":0}}

I would expect both SUB and PUB to follow MQTT_FULLTOPIC but it shows that SUB does follow MQTT_FULLTOPIC where PUB only uses "PUB_PREFIX"

nodes are running 5.9.1

arendst commented 6 years ago

@pcopa if you set the fallbacktopic (being mqttClient) equal to Mqtt topic you may expect this result as the latter two are provided using the fallbacktopic and is as designed. Fallback topic is just that: a fallback in case you forget the Mqtt topic and the result will always NOT use the full topic.

@daballiemo looks the same situation.

Bottomline: Use different names for MQTTClient and MQTT topic.

user34756361233 commented 6 years ago

@arendst,

thx for your quick respons. I have changed my setup to what I think I understand in your response. I however still have one issue, when firing a statusupdate for among others the firmware version; using the same build (5.9.1.a)

Sonoff Basic: 16:51:28 RSL: Received Topic home/esp8266/tasmota/sonoff_2A16BC/cmnd/status, Data Size 1, Data 2 16:51:28 RSL: Group 0, Index 1, Command STATUS, Data 2 16:51:29 MQT: home/esp8266/tasmota/sonoff_2A16BC/STATUS2 = {"StatusFWR":{"Version":"5.9.1a", "BuildDateTime":"2017-11-10T16:41:02", "Boot":5, "Core":"2_3_0", "SDK":"1.5.3(aec24ac9)"}}

H801: 16:51:29 RSL: Received Topic home/esp8266/tasmota/sonoff_D65C77/cmnd/status, Data Size 1, Data 2 16:51:29 RSL: Group 0, Index 1, Command STATUS, Data 2 16:51:29 MQT: stat/sonoff_D65C77/STATUS2 = {"StatusFWR":{"Version":"5.9.1a", "BuildDateTime":"2017-11-10T16:41:02", "Boot":31, "Core":"2_3_0", "SDK":"1.5.3(aec24ac9)"}}

what can be seen is that it looks like the MQTT respons of the H801 does not respect the settings in user_config.h even not after reset: 17:01:55 RSL: Received Topic /Fulltopic, Data Size 1, Data 1 17:01:55 RSL: Group 0, Index 1, Command FULLTOPIC, Data 1 17:01:55 MQT: home/esp8266/tasmota/sonoff_D65C77/stat/RESULT = {"FullTopic":"home/esp8266/tasmota/%topic%/%prefix%/"} 17:02:00 MQT: home/esp8266/tasmota/sonoff_D65C77/tele/UPTIME = {"Time":"2017-11-10T17:02:00", "Uptime":1} 17:02:13 WIF: Checking connection... 17:02:13 WIF: Connected 17:03:36 RSL: Received Topic home/esp8266/tasmota/sonoff_D65C77/cmnd/status, Data Size 1, Data 2 17:03:36 RSL: Group 0, Index 1, Command STATUS, Data 2 17:03:36 MQT: stat/sonoff_D65C77/STATUS2 = {"StatusFWR":{"Version":"5.9.1a", "BuildDateTime":"2017-11-10T16:41:02", "Boot":31, "Core":"2_3_0", "SDK":"1.5.3(aec24ac9)"}}

arendst commented 6 years ago

Check your MQTTClient and Topic for the H801. Apparently they are still the same.

Use commands mqttclient and topic to check and/or update.

pcopa commented 6 years ago

@ Thanks for the prompt response. I'm new to MQTT and will need some more time to dig into the fallback topic before I get back to you. I'm using HomeAssistant and was confused because I've been doing OTA updates for 2 months with the same configuration (full topic) without any issues and suddenly the behavior changed.

user34756361233 commented 6 years ago

I have changed my setup as instructed and everything is now working as it should.

thx

pcopa commented 6 years ago

I've also changed my configuration for all my modules and now everything is working fine. What I have learned, (with the help of @arendst), is that the "Configuration->Configure Other->Friendly Name 1 = "xyz" name and the name in the topic .../.../xyz/... can NOT be the same. In my case I have added the prefix "m" (for module) to all my names (mxyz) in all the mqtt topics. Thanks P.S. This item can be closed

stale[bot] commented 6 years ago

This issue has been automatically marked as stale because it has not had recent activity. It will be closed if no further activity occurs. Thank you for your contributions.

stale[bot] commented 6 years ago

This issue will be auto-closed because there hasn't been any activity for a few months. Feel free to open a new one if you still experience this problem.