arfc / 2018-bae-benchmark

Benchmark paper for Cyclus
GNU General Public License v3.0
1 stars 2 forks source link

Reviewer final question #17

Open katyhuff opened 5 years ago

katyhuff commented 5 years ago

Nearly ready to submit. There is one remaining reviewer question and I'm not actually sure how to respond.

Question: Figure 6: At least visually, the mean behavior over the oscillations does not appear consistent with the reference. Is this the case? If so, comment. If not, describe why it is not.

image

What do you think, @jbae11 ? My best guess is that the \Cyclus simulation and the model solution exactly match at the only one point of each year, following discharge from the storage facility. The model solution is based on a yearly accounting and thus, perhaps fails to capture the detail about the buildup of inventory over the course of the year.