arfc / msbr-reproc

holds a paper describing an MSBR online reprocessing demonstration.
BSD 3-Clause "New" or "Revised" License
6 stars 4 forks source link

Reviewer #3 minor comments #35

Closed andrewryh closed 5 years ago

andrewryh commented 5 years ago

Reviewer 2 (comments related with Reviewer 3):

andrewryh commented 5 years ago

In Page 21, it looks like the neutron spectrum is not normalized in Figure 10. It is recommended to normalize the neutron spectrum for comparison.

What does it mean normalized? In my case integral under the spectrum curve =1 (calculate by numpy.trapz). Probably, he meant some other type of normalization? By average? I have no idea.

katyhuff commented 5 years ago
  1. How did the authors verify the coupled SaltProc and Serpent code system?

Remind the reviewer that we mention comparison to Ben, and made some comparison with Park. Note that future releases will contain significant generalization of the method as well as a suite of unit tests.

  1. In Page 21, it looks like the neutron spectrum is not normalized in Figure 10. It is recommended to normalize the neutron spectrum for comparison.

Tell the reviewer that this is per lethargy and the area under the curve is normalized to 1. (add the normalization under the curve to the caption)

  1. Too much background information was contained in the abstract, which deteriorates the readability of the abstract.

@katyhuff can work on this.