Tasmota KNX functions - Githubissues

WoutervanZijl commented 3 years ago

PROBLEM DESCRIPTION

A clear and concise description of what the problem is. Currently i have a few device with Tasmota KNX but i canot find any option to choose like relay or button or anything, The only option i have is to select a output in the configuration menu of knx. My modules are Sonoff 4 ch pro and 3 sonoff basics all with tasmota knx 9.1. I have searched online but only see picture on the tasmota knx wiki where there is a button selected or humidity and other option. Am i doing something wrong or is there more info hidden or coming.

What i would like if possible is to program my sonoff 4ch pro so that my rf buttons are seperate from the sonoff device to start scene or indeed switch a relay so that its more programmeble to amazing idees:)

I realy like knx and if I could help in any way or test ( not a programmer but a enthousiast for sure)

Hope this the correct way of communicating because i dit tryed the chat but no luck there.

REQUESTED INFORMATION

Make sure your have performed every step and checked the applicable boxes before submitting your issue. Thank you!

[x] Read the Contributing Guide and Policy and the Code of Conduct
[x] Searched the problem in issues
[x] Searched the problem in the docs
[x] Searched the problem in the forum
[x] Searched the problem in the chat
[x] Device used (e.g., Sonoff Basic): _sonoff 4ch pro and sonoff basic
[x] Tasmota binary firmware version number used: _9.1tasmota knx
- [ ] Pre-compiled
- [ ] Self-compiled
- [ ] IDE / Compiler used: _____
[x] Flashing tools used: _____tasmotizer
[ ] Provide the output of command: Backlog Template; Module; GPIO 255:
```
Configuration output here:
```

- [ ] If using rules, provide the output of this command: `Backlog Rule1; Rule2; Rule3`:

Rules output here:

- [ ] Provide the output of this command: `Status 0`:

STATUS 0 output here:

- [ ] Provide the output of the Console log output when you experience your issue; if applicable:
  _(Please use_ `weblog 4` _for more debug information)_

Console output here:



### TO REPRODUCE
_Steps to reproduce the behavior:_

### EXPECTED BEHAVIOUR
_A clear and concise description of what you expected to happen._

### SCREENSHOTS
_If applicable, add screenshots to help explain your problem._

### ADDITIONAL CONTEXT
_Add any other context about the problem here._

**(Please, remember to close the issue when the problem has been addressed)**

ascillato commented 3 years ago

... i canot find any option to choose like relay or button or anything ...

The available options for KNX Web Menu, are only the ones defined at https://tasmota.github.io/docs/KNX/#implemented-features

To be able to select any of those, you must have them defined under MODULE CONFIGURATION. If your device have a relay and you can operate it using the main page of Tasmota, you will have it as OUTPUT in the KNX web menu.

What i would like if possible is to program my sonoff 4ch pro so that my rf buttons are seperate from the sonoff device to start scene or indeed switch a relay

To use the RF buttons for scenes, you need to use rules. You can use the KnxTx_scene command in those rules to send a KNX scene.

ascillato commented 3 years ago

If you have further questions, please just ask.

WoutervanZijl commented 3 years ago

Thank you very much for you’re answer. I got it working now🥳🥳but the knx version that is different when i start this. 9.1.0 does not have buttons. Then is clicked another link to a other binaries. Tasmota knx 9.1.0.2 does have buttons. But 5 minutes ago after more googling i found diferent page with knx with language and version 9.0.0.2

Keep using this page for the best experience? Where version 9.0.0.2 is found?

Also I tried to add a device with ets5 demo. I could not get it working. How to ad a dummy (i have added a gira dummy, but then I got stuck🙈 I think I need to google more about ets5 anyway.

I you have advice to get it running with basics in knx5, I would love to hear.

Very nice to use a button and more lichts go on🥳

Great firmware.

ascillato commented 3 years ago

Tasmota main repository is https://github.com/arendst/Tasmota

The latest Tasmota version is at http://ota.tasmota.com/tasmota

Also you can set into your Tasmota (from upgrade firmware in the webmenu) the latest KNX Tasmota version with http://ota.tasmota.com/tasmota/tasmota-knx.bin.gz so you can just do one click and Tasmota will take care automatically of all the update process (download, free space in flash, flash the new file, etc.)

This repository is a fork that I use to develop new KNX functions for Tasmota. For testing I also share the precompiled bins in all supported languages at https://github.com/ascillato/Tasmota_KNX/releases/latest but they are not the latest. Tasmota is being updated nearly everyday. The latest Tasmota with all the fixes (including KNX fixes) is at the official http://ota.tasmota.com/tasmota/tasmota-knx.bin.gz

For adding a dummy switch in ETS, please search in YouTube. There are plenty of videos showing exactly how to add it.

WoutervanZijl commented 3 years ago

Thank you for responding. Do I need a Knx ip interface or router to get a connection? If I google I only find stuf about interfaces or routers.

ascillato commented 3 years ago

If you have a KNX network on TP(twisted pair comms), RF(radio frequency comms) or PL(power line comms), you need an interface to connect your knx network to your LAN network.

Tasmota uses the KNX IP protocol, so it needs just wifi to communicate to other Tasmotas, but if you want to interact to your KNX network you need to connect it to your wifi/lan network. Also, the KNX IP interface must support KNX IP Multicast to use Tasmota. As far as I know, nowadays all LAN-KNX interfaces supports KNX IP Multicast. KNX Tunneling is not supported in Tasmota.

WoutervanZijl commented 3 years ago

So if I understand it correctly. To configure tasmota with ETS5 I need a knx interface? Or can I connect to Tasmota different? I have no any other knx devices. Only Tasmota.

I my head I thought i would just connect to the same wifi network as Tasmota knx and Add a device and configure it.

ascillato commented 3 years ago

To configure Tasmota you only need to access Tasmota webUI. No need for anything else.

Tasmota KNX has its own web menu for configuring.

For ETS, there is no config to Tasmota. You don't need ETS for Tasmota. You need ETS for KNX hardware only.

If you have several Tasmota devices, they can communicate between each other using KNX over your wifi network. There is no need for extra hardware or software.

WoutervanZijl commented 3 years ago

Yes i have seen that. But If I would like to play with it more and ets5 is it possible without interface or router to connect?

ascillato commented 3 years ago

Also, if you have a Home Automation software like for example HOME ASSISTANT, you can make your devices to communicate to that using KNX IP. Also you can do the same using MQTT.

ascillato commented 3 years ago

But If I would like to play with it more and ets5 is it possible without interface or router to connect?

Tasmota can't be configured from ETS. Tasmota KNX must be configured using its own web menu.

WoutervanZijl commented 3 years ago

Yes When i learn more i will use home assistand indeed. I like knx more and its been here for long time. Maybe expanding with hager and knx rf

ascillato commented 3 years ago

ETS is for configuring KNX hardware. Depending on your KNX Network type, is the adapter you need. For example, if you have KNX IP devices, you need just a PC connected to your wifi router. If you have a KNX-TP, you need the serial to TP adapter or any other adapter to communicate to KNX TP and config it.

WoutervanZijl commented 3 years ago

But If I would like to play with it more and ets5 is it possible without interface or router to connect?

Tasmota can't be configured from ETS. Tasmota KNX must be configured using its own web menu.

Ah oke nice to know. What is possible with ets if i make a dummy device. Only for connecting commands to an from a different knx line?

ascillato commented 3 years ago

For KNX RF you need indeed an interface but that is not related to Tasmota. Tasmota offers a support for some functionalities over KNX IP in order to be able to accept and sends commands to other Tasmotas and to KNX devices, but is not a KNX hardware, so it isn't configurable under ETS.

ascillato commented 3 years ago

What is possible with ets if i make a dummy device.

Nothing. Tasmota can't be configured from ETS. Only from its own web menu.

WoutervanZijl commented 3 years ago

Ah oke nice. I thought maybe to get a cheaper knx system in my house 😁

One question about reading a device. If i program a button to a relay en then the output to another tasmota and then back to again a different relay. If i press realy fast twice then they are not all on. the first i press is out again. Is it possible to read the status?

ascillato commented 3 years ago

The dummy device in ETS is only useful when you are programming an entire KNX network. For example, If you are telling in ETS that a KNX switch must send an ON command to the Group address 2.2.2 and that GA is not related to anything (only your Tasmota device), ETS will tell you that the GA 2.2.2 is not associated to anything. So, for eliminating that error, you must tell ETS that GA 2.2.2 is a dummy device.

WoutervanZijl commented 3 years ago

The dummy device in ETS is only useful when you are programming an entire KNX network. For example, If you are telling in ETS that a KNX switch must send an ON command to the Group address 2.2.2 and that GA is not related to anything (only your Tasmota device), ETS will tell you that the GA 2.2.2 is not associated to anything. So, for eliminating that error, you must tell ETS that GA 2.2.2 is a dummy device.

Yes clear thank you!

ascillato commented 3 years ago

I thought maybe to get a cheaper knx system in my house

You can, with Tasmota you can have a mixed device type network. Using KNX or MQTT.

Choosing KNX or any other Smart Home system is just about how are the properties you want. How reliable it is, its support, its expandability, if it supports diy devices, and price.

ascillato commented 3 years ago

One question about reading a device. If i program a button to a relay en then the output to another tasmota and then back to again a different relay. If i press realy fast twice then they are not all on. the first i press is out again. Is it possible to read the status?

Hehehe, you need to test that. Follow the example on the Tasmota docs and you will see. It is pretty reliable the comms.

And yes, you can read the actual status of a relay.

ascillato commented 3 years ago

If you don't have any KNX device, you can evaluate if it is the right choice for you or not.

If you just wanted to play with ETS and a KNX device, Tasmota is not a solution to that for now. If you want that, I can search in my notes that there is another library that supports ETS programming. It isn't as complete as Tasmota and you will need to code and compile to use it. Tell me if you want that. Is in github.

EDIT: The other KNX library that supports ETS Programming is https://github.com/thelsing/knx

WoutervanZijl commented 3 years ago

One question about reading a device. If i program a button to a relay en then the output to another tasmota and then back to again a different relay. If i press realy fast twice then they are not all on. the first i press is out again. Is it possible to read the status?

Hehehe, you need to test that. Follow the example on the Tasmota docs and you will see. It is pretty reliable the comms.

And yes, you can read the actual status of a relay.

I did and it worked great😁 But I noticed that. Because when I use it in the staircase and the button is pushed realy fast its the other way around. I wil test more and find out👌

WoutervanZijl commented 3 years ago

If you don't have any KNX device, you can evaluate if it is the right choice for you or not.

If you just wanted to play with ETS and a KNX device, Tasmota is not a solution to that for now. If you want that, I can search in my notes that there is another library that supports ETS programming. It isn't as complete as Tasmota and you will need to code and compile to use it. Tell me if you want that. Is in github.

Oh I am am not experienced in what to do with code🙈

WoutervanZijl commented 3 years ago

... i canot find any option to choose like relay or button or anything ...

The available options for KNX Web Menu, are only the ones defined at https://tasmota.github.io/docs/KNX/#implemented-features

To be able to select any of those, you must have them defined under MODULE CONFIGURATION. If your device have a relay and you can operate it using the main page of Tasmota, you will have it as OUTPUT in the KNX web menu.

What i would like if possible is to program my sonoff 4ch pro so that my rf buttons are seperate from the sonoff device to start scene or indeed switch a relay

To use the RF buttons for scenes, you need to use rules. You can use the KnxTx_scene command in those rules to send a KNX scene.

Hey ascillato, is it possible to use the rf buttons separate from the sonoff switxh itself? Normaly you link a button pres to the sonoff switch 1 and when switching it goes on. Can this be seperat So that when button pressed the switch does not toggle But does Send a message to knx.

How exactly can I add rf to a tasmota scene

ascillato commented 3 years ago

Please, set weblog to 4 and paste here the output of the console when you receive the signal from the rf. Thanks.

WoutervanZijl commented 3 years ago

Please, set weblog to 4 and paste here the output of the console when you receive the signal from the rf. Thanks.

Yes I did what you asked.

Saved to flash at F4, Count 414, Bytes 4096 09:10:05 WIF: Checking connection... 09:10:18 APP: Button1 level 1-0 09:10:18 KNX: Button 1 = 1 sent to 1.1.10 09:10:18 SRC: Button 09:10:18 RSL: RESULT = {"POWER1":"ON"} 09:10:18 RSL: POWER1 = ON 09:10:19 CFG: Saved to flash at FB, Count 415, Bytes 4096 09:10:19 APP: Button1 level 0-1 09:10:25 WIF: Checking connection... 09:10:35 SRC: WebGui from 192.168.1.5 09:10:35 RSL: RESULT = {"POWER1":"OFF"} 09:10:35 RSL: POWER1 = OFF 09:10:36 CFG: Saved to flash at FA, Count 416, Bytes 4096 09:10:37 HTP: Configuration 09:10:41 HTP: Main Menu 09:10:42 HTP: Console 09:10:45 WIF: Checking connection... 09:10:54 APP: Button1 level 1-0 09:10:54 KNX: Button 1 = 1 sent to 1.1.10 09:10:54 SRC: Button 09:10:54 RSL: RESULT = {"POWER1":"ON"} 09:10:54 RSL: POWER1 = ON 09:10:54 APP: Button1 level 0-1 09:10:55 CFG: Saved to flash at F9, Count 417, Bytes 4096 09:11:05 WIF: Checking connection... 09:11:08 APP: Button1 level 1-0 09:11:08 KNX: Button 1 = 1 sent to 1.1.10 09:11:08 SRC: Button 09:11:08 RSL: RESULT = {"POWER1":"OFF"} 09:11:08 RSL: POWER1 = OFF 09:11:08 APP: Button1 level 0-1 09:11:09 CFG: Saved to flash at F8, Count 418, Bytes 4096 09:11:22 HTP: Main Menu 09:11:25 WIF: Checking connection... 09:11:27 APP: Button3 level 1-0 09:11:27 SRC: Button 09:11:27 RSL: RESULT = {"POWER3":"ON"} 09:11:27 RSL: POWER3 = ON 09:11:27 APP: Button3 level 0-1 09:11:28 CFG: Saved to flash at F7, Count 419, Bytes 4096 09:11:28 APP: Button4 level 1-0 09:11:28 SRC: Button 09:11:28 RSL: RESULT = {"POWER4":"ON"} 09:11:28 RSL: POWER4 = ON 09:11:29 CFG: Saved to flash at F6, Count 420, Bytes 4096 09:11:29 APP: Button4 level 0-1 09:11:32 HTP: Console 09:11:45 WIF: Checking connection... 09:12:05 WIF: Checking connection... 09:12:25 WIF: Checking connection... 09:12:45 WIF: Checking connection... 09:13:05 WIF: Checking connection...

I know i can send a command from the rf device to the sonof switch and it turns the switch on. Can I also make this seperate? So that 1 press button one and nothing happen but it switches a on signal to knx groep 1.1.1 for instance?

Same af with a scene. So that when its pressed button one the switchlink is off.

Cheers

ascillato commented 3 years ago

Can I also make this seperate? So that 1 press button one and nothing happen but it switches a on signal to knx groep 1.1.1 for instance?

In Tasmota web menu:

go to CONFIGURATION, then CONFIGURE TEMPLATE
select Sonoff 4 ch pro as BASED ON.
change button1 to switch1
go to CONFIGURE OTHER
select activate template. (Now the behavior is the same as before, but your button1 can be controlled easily with rules)

go to the console and type:

Switchmode1 0
Switchtopic 0
Rule1 1
Rule1 on switch1#state do knxtx_cmnd1 1 endon

go to the KNX web menu and set KNX TX Slot1 as 1/1/1

Now every time you press button1 or the RF button1, your device won't change the state of relay1 but will send a ON to 1/1/1

(The RF button1 and the physical button1, are the same input in your device - they can not be separated as they are connected in the hardware to the same GPIO of the ESP8266)

WoutervanZijl commented 3 years ago

Can I also make this seperate? So that 1 press button one and nothing happen but it switches a on signal to knx groep 1.1.1 for instance?

In Tasmota web menu:

go to CONFIGURATION, then CONFIGURE TEMPLATE

select Sonoff 4 ch pro as BASED ON.

change button1 to switch1

go to CONFIGURE OTHER

select activate template. (Now the behavior is the same as before, but your button1 can be controlled easily with rules)

go to the console and type:
Switchmode1 0
Switchtopic 0
Rule1 1
Rule1 on switch1#state do knxtx_cmnd1 1 endon
go to the KNX web menu and set KNX TX Slot1 as 1/1/1

Now every time you press button1 or the RF button1, your device won't change the state of relay1 but will send a ON to 1/1/1

(The RF button1 and the physical button1, are the same input in your device - they can not be separated as they are connected in the hardware to the same GPIO of the ESP8266)

When i put in switchtopic 0 command unknown.

And for switch 2 i put in the same but then change rule1 on switch 2?

About the physical connection with rf and the button I understand. This is what i wanted thank you.

Is there progres with a dimmer with knx maybe?🙏🏻

ascillato commented 3 years ago

When i put in switchtopic 0, command unknown.

May there was a typo when introducing the command? It is SwitchTopic Anyway, don't worry, the zero is the default, but must be zero in order to let the rules uses the switches.

And for switch 2 i put in the same but then change rule1 on switch 2?

Yes, exactly.

Is there progres with a dimmer with knx maybe?

Yes, but I do that only on my free time, that is very limited right now. I need to pay the bills ;) So, please, be patient. Thanks.

ascillato commented 3 years ago

You can check the progress on the dimming and RGB functions on the feature request https://github.com/arendst/Tasmota/issues/7438

WoutervanZijl commented 3 years ago

When i put in switchtopic 0, command unknown.

May there was a typo when introducing the command? It is SwitchTopic Anyway, don't worry, the zero is the default, but must be zero in order to let the rules uses the switches.

And for switch 2 i put in the same but then change rule1 on switch 2?

Yes, exactly.

Is there progres with a dimmer with knx maybe?

Yes, but I do that only on my free time, that is very limited right now. I need to pay the bills ;) So, please, be patient. Thanks.

Nice I got it to work yes💪 I feel I got in late with tasmota and stil finding how it work with rules and everything.

Nice to hear there that its in the making knx rgb! Does that also implies for instance the schelly dimmer with knx. Just different programming

ascillato commented 3 years ago

Does that also implies for instance the schelly dimmer with knx.

Yes

WoutervanZijl commented 3 years ago

Very nice Adrian👌

Van: Adrian Scillato notifications@github.com Verzonden: Tuesday, December 1, 2020 1:19:54 PM Aan: ascillato/Tasmota_KNX Tasmota_KNX@noreply.github.com CC: WoutervanZijl woutervanzijl_@hotmail.com; Author author@noreply.github.com Onderwerp: Re: [ascillato/Tasmota_KNX] Tasmota KNX functions (#563)

Does that also implies for instance the schelly dimmer with knx.

Yes

— You are receiving this because you authored the thread. Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHubhttps://github.com/ascillato/Tasmota_KNX/issues/563#issuecomment-736517311, or unsubscribehttps://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AR235RBHQ5JE6QYVIVANZM3SSTNOVANCNFSM4T52L2UQ.

WoutervanZijl commented 3 years ago

Hello Adrian, I borrowed from school alot of knx devices and also an ip interface.

Ik have a question about what i need to connect 20 tasmota knx devices to knx. Do I require a knx router? Or is that something different for other uses? Can i simple connect the ip interface to a wifi router en connect all de device to that wifi router?

Thanks

ascillato commented 3 years ago

Can i simple connect the ip interface to a wifi router en connect all de device to that wifi router?

Exactly.

WoutervanZijl commented 3 years ago

Hi i have bought myself a sonof rf bridge. Now was I wondering how can i use more then 5 channels. I can make rules but there are only 5 slots for this. Can I expand that?

ascillato commented 3 years ago

As you said, you can using rules.

WoutervanZijl commented 3 years ago

Mm oke. Could you provide me a start line😁 So you mean I can make rx6 wit rules then?

Van: Adrian Scillato notifications@github.com Verzonden: Thursday, January 7, 2021 6:03:57 PM Aan: ascillato/Tasmota_KNX Tasmota_KNX@noreply.github.com CC: WoutervanZijl woutervanzijl_@hotmail.com; Author author@noreply.github.com Onderwerp: Re: [ascillato/Tasmota_KNX] Tasmota KNX functions (#563)

As you said, you can using rules.

— You are receiving this because you authored the thread. Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHubhttps://github.com/ascillato/Tasmota_KNX/issues/563#issuecomment-756245106, or unsubscribehttps://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AR235RC32LJWRDZCVVCIRI3SYXSP3ANCNFSM4T52L2UQ.

ascillato commented 3 years ago

Yes, you can adapt the RF Bridge example of the docs to send your desired commands by KNX.

https://tasmota.github.io/docs/Rules/#rf-repeater-ir-repeater

WoutervanZijl commented 3 years ago

Thanks for all the responses. I find it very Difficult to understand the the programming in the console. I got it working to send a knx signal from a button of the remote but it does the same on every button. With some googling i found a diferent rule line but i can not get it to work.

18:25:35.444 RSL: tele/tasmota_00ED6A/RESULT = {"Time":"2021-01-09T18:25:35","RfReceived":{"Sync":8730,"Low":290,"High":870,"Data":"9CD468","RfKey":"None"}} 18:25:57.720 CMD: Rule1 on RfReceived#Data=94D568 do KnxTx_Cmnd1 0 endon 18:25:57.726 RUL: Stored uncompressed, would compress from 48 to 41 (-15%) 18:25:57.731 RSL: stat/tasmota_00ED6A/RESULT = {"Rule1":"ON","Once":"OFF","StopOnError":"OFF","Length":48,"Free":463,"Rules":"on RfReceived#Data=94D568 do KnxTx_Cmnd1 0 endon"} 18:26:00.583 RSL: tele/tasmota_00ED6A/RESULT = {"Time":"2021-01-09T18:26:00","RfReceived":{"Sync":8710,"Low":300,"High":870,"Data":"9CD568","RfKey":"None"}} 18:26:08.950 RSL: tele/tasmota_00ED6A/RESULT = {"Time":"2021-01-09T18:26:08","RfReceived":{"Sync":8710,"Low":300,"High":870,"Data":"9CD568","RfKey":"None"}} 18:26:13.156 RSL: tele/tasmota_00ED6A/RESULT = {"Time":"2021-01-09T18:26:13","RfReceived":{"Sync":8710,"Low":300,"High":870,"Data":"9CD568","RfKey":"None"}}

rule1 on RfReceived#Data=94D568 do KnxTx_Cmnd1 0 endon

I also dont understand how to make the rule where I can make my own rule to send knx 1/1/1

I got 5 tx slots but a 10 button remote. Got KnxTx_Cmnd1 working but now without this for knx slot 6,7,8,9,10

Thx for the help

ascillato commented 3 years ago

Yes, you are right. There are only 5 slots for storing KNX Group Addresses.

By now, you have reach the maximum amount of slots. This was a limitation by design due to how Tasmota was using the eeprom for settings. As it is now, this can not be increased without corrupting the settings area.

I'm working on a refactoring of the whole KNX driver and libraries to use the new way of storing settings that Tasmota has now, in order to allow more slots and add more versatility on the KNX message types. Until then, you can only use 5 slots. Sorry.

WoutervanZijl commented 3 years ago

Don’t be sorry for that😁 the fact we can use knx for this is awesome. Ordered another sonof bridge for a solution for now.

But I have not figured out how to get the remote working.

rule1 on RfReceived do KnxTx_Cmnd1 0 endon

If i use this rule then all the 5 buttons do the same. How can I seperate this?

this rule is also not working. rule1 on RfReceived#Data=94D568 do KnxTx_Cmnd1 0 endon

what am i missing?

WoutervanZijl commented 3 years ago

Oke I got it working to revieve my remote command from 1 button to send a knx cmd. But when i type in the cmd for the second button it works but the my first rule disappears.🙈

RFRECEIVED#DATA=9CD569tele/tasmota_00ED6A/RESULT = {"Time":"2021-01-20T17:16:18","RfReceived":{"Sync":8730,"Low":300,"High":870,"Data":"9CD568","RfKey":1}} 17:16:18.225 RUL: RFRECEIVED#DATA=9CD568 performs "KnxTx_Cmnd1 1" 17:16:18.231 KNX: KNX TX 1 = 1 sent to 2.1.1 17:16:18.235 RSL: stat/tasmota_00ED6A/RESULT = {"KnxTx_Cmnd1":"1"} 17:16:45.219 CMD: rule1 on RFRECEIVED#DATA=9CD564 do KnxTx_Cmnd2 2 endon 17:16:45.226 RUL: Stored uncompressed, would compress from 48 to 44 (-8%) 17:16:45.230 RSL: stat/tasmota_00ED6A/RESULT = {"Rule1":"ON","Once":"OFF","StopOnError":"OFF","Length":48,"Free":463,"Rules":"on RFRECEIVED#DATA=9CD564 do KnxTx_Cmnd2 2 endon"} 17:16:47.380 RSL: tele/tasmota_00ED6A/RESULT = {"Time":"2021-01-20T17:16:47","RfReceived":{"Sync":8720,"Low":300,"High":870,"Data":"9CD564","RfKey":2}} 17:16:47.394 RUL: RFRECEIVED#DATA=9CD564 performs "KnxTx_Cmnd2 2" 17:16:47.400 KNX: KNX TX 2 = 1 sent to 2.1.2 17:16:47.408 RSL: stat/tasmota_00ED6A/RESULT = {"KnxTx_Cmnd2":"2"} 17:16:50.076 RSL: tele/tasmota_00ED6A/RESULT = {"Time":"2021-01-20T17:16:50","RfReceived":{"Sync":8710,"Low":300,"High":870,"Data":"9CD568","RfKey":1}} 17:16:52.139 RSL: tele/tasmota_00ED6A/RESULT = {"Time":"2021-01-20T17:16:52","RfReceived":{"Sync":8710,"Low":300,"High":870,"Data":"9CD568","RfKey":1}}

What am i doing wrong? Also i cant find any info why after knxtx_cmd there is a 1?

ascillato commented 3 years ago

...but the my first rule disappears...

From the docs at https://tasmota.github.io/docs/Commands/#rules

So, you can save you rules all together as:

rule1 1
rule1 on RFRECEIVED#DATA=9CD568 do KnxTx_Cmnd1 1 endon on RFRECEIVED#DATA=9CD564 do KnxTx_Cmnd2 1 endon

or save one rule and append a new one as:

rule1 1
rule1 on RFRECEIVED#DATA=9CD568 do KnxTx_Cmnd1 1 endon
rule1 +on RFRECEIVED#DATA=9CD564 do KnxTx_Cmnd2 1 endon

You have 3 Sets for rules (RULE1, RULE2, RULE3). Each Set can have a lot of rules until there is no more free space on that rule set. Using RULE1 ON .... will OVERWRITE everything you have in rule set 1. Using RULE1 +ON .... will ADD what you want to the rule set 1.

Also i cant find any info why after knxtx_cmd there is a 1?

From the docs at https://tasmota.github.io/docs/Commands/#knx

The command structure is

_knxtxcmdX command

X is the KNX slot where you have set the GroupAddress to send this command. That KNX Slot must be completed by you in the Tasmota KNX web menu with the KNX address you want to send the command.
command is the command you want to send. 0 for Turn it OFF and 1 for Turn it ON.

For example. If, you want to send the commands TURN ON / TURN OFF to the KNX Address 2.2.3 and 2.2.4

1- Config the addresses on the KNX Slots

2- Set the rules in the console

code 9CD568 to turn on 2.2.3
code 9CD567 to turn off 2.2.3
code 9CD564 to turn on 2.2.4
code 9CD565 to turn off 2.2.4

rule1 1
rule1 on RFRECEIVED#DATA=9CD568 do KnxTx_Cmnd1 1 endon on RFRECEIVED#DATA=9CD567 do KnxTx_Cmnd1 0 endon on RFRECEIVED#DATA=9CD564 do KnxTx_Cmnd2 1 endon on RFRECEIVED#DATA=9CD565 do KnxTx_Cmnd2 0 endon

3-Enjoy :smile:

WoutervanZijl commented 3 years ago

Thank yo uso much!!!!!!! I got it working 😊😊😊

Van: Adrian Scillato notifications@github.com Verzonden: woensdag 20 januari 2021 19:45 Aan: ascillato/Tasmota_KNX Tasmota_KNX@noreply.github.com CC: WoutervanZijl woutervanzijl_@hotmail.com; Author author@noreply.github.com Onderwerp: Re: [ascillato/Tasmota_KNX] Tasmota KNX functions (#563)

...but the my first rule disappears...

From the docs at https://tasmota.github.io/docs/Commands/#rules

[image]https://user-images.githubusercontent.com/35405447/105217500-b0f0de00-5b32-11eb-90e4-c8e13482c860.png

So, you can save you rules all together as:

rule1 1

rule1 on RFRECEIVED#DATA=9CD568 do KnxTx_Cmnd1 1 endon on RFRECEIVED#DATA=9CD564 do KnxTx_Cmnd2 1 endon

or save one rule and append a new one as:

rule1 1

rule1 on RFRECEIVED#DATA=9CD568 do KnxTx_Cmnd1 1 endon

rule1 +on RFRECEIVED#DATA=9CD564 do KnxTx_Cmnd2 1 endon

You have 3 Sets for rules (RULE1, RULE2, RULE3). Each Set can have a lot of rules until there is no more free space on that rule set. Using RULE1 ON .... will OVERWRITE everything you have in rule set 1. Using RULE1 +ON .... will ADD what you want to the rule set 1.

Also i cant find any info why after knxtx_cmd there is a 1?

From the docs at https://tasmota.github.io/docs/Commands/#knx

The command structure is

knxtx_cmdX command

X is the KNX slot where you have set the GroupAddress to send this command. That KNX Slot must be completed by you in the Tasmota KNX web menu with the KNX address you want to send the command.
command is the command you want to send. 0 for Turn it OFF and 1 for Turn it ON.

For example. If, you want to send the commands TURN ON / TURN OFF to the KNX Address 2.2.3 and 2.2.4

1- Config the addresses on the KNX Slots

[image]https://user-images.githubusercontent.com/35405447/105219628-6fadfd80-5b35-11eb-8aaf-283eb4d02aae.png

2- Set the rules in the console

code 9CD568 to turn on 2.2.3
code 9CD567 to turn off 2.2.3
code 9CD564 to turn on 2.2.4
code 9CD565 to turn off 2.2.4

rule1 1

rule1 on RFRECEIVED#DATA=9CD568 do KnxTx_Cmnd1 1 endon on RFRECEIVED#DATA=9CD567 do KnxTx_Cmnd1 0 endon on RFRECEIVED#DATA=9CD564 do KnxTx_Cmnd2 1 endon on RFRECEIVED#DATA=9CD565 do KnxTx_Cmnd2 0 endon

3-Enjoy :)

— You are receiving this because you authored the thread. Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHubhttps://github.com/ascillato/Tasmota_KNX/issues/563#issuecomment-763854532, or unsubscribehttps://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AR235RCZUCG24OBEKF6LYO3S24QD3ANCNFSM4T52L2UQ.

WoutervanZijl commented 3 years ago

I am seeing some issue with changing knx commands. For testing purposes i had send knx code 2/1/2 to the one light so that my girlfriend was able to use it with the remote. But after removing al the knx commands the licht stil respond to knx 2/1/2. Am I doing something wrong? Does it needs full reset first somewhere. I had another light doing the same but i did a full reset and put new knx commands in the slot for recieving and it worked again. ![Uploading 8648FCD3-10FB-46CB-A83B-EE79482F08CD.png…]()

WoutervanZijl commented 3 years ago

![Uploading E1E34B15-65F7-482A-B492-FB5F37DBA55B.png…]() ![Uploading 2428345C-2D0C-436E-AE28-72CC31F105B0.png…]()

WoutervanZijl commented 3 years ago

![Uploading AC852795-2B54-4DBD-9141-CB3420AF93DA.png…]()

ascillato commented 3 years ago

Sorry, I don't understand your issue. Please elaborate.

ascillato / Tasmota_KNX

Tasmota KNX functions #563

PROBLEM DESCRIPTION

REQUESTED INFORMATION

...but the my first rule disappears...

Also i cant find any info why after knxtx_cmd there is a 1?