ashleythomasbarnes / phangs

Projects relating to PHANGS
0 stars 0 forks source link

ngc1385 #7

Open ashleythomasbarnes opened 2 years ago

ashleythomasbarnes commented 2 years ago

The QA report checklist for this galaxy Please complete as you progress through the QA All data for galaxies can be obtained here

Checklist

lneumann95 commented 2 years ago

[ngc1385_7m_hcop_image_trimmed_k]: wavy baseline for region in the centre ngc1385_7m_hcop_image_trimmed_k_QA

lneumann95 commented 2 years ago

velocity axis of CS maps inverted

lneumann95 commented 2 years ago

[ngc1385_7m_cs_image_trimmed_k]: negative bowling ngc1385_7m_cs_image_trimmed_k_QA

lneumann95 commented 2 years ago

residual maps are missing the beam units

lneumann95 commented 2 years ago

[ngc1385_7m_hcop_residual_trimmed]: significant positive residual in channel 68 ngc1385_7m_hcop_residual_trimmed_QA

lneumann95 commented 2 years ago

[7m+tp images]: significantly higher noise at the edges (which I guess is normal?): example below ngc1385_7m+tp_hcn_pbcorr_trimmed_k_QA

lneumann95 commented 2 years ago

overall the data looks very noisy and there is almost no significant emission in the cubes

lneumann95 commented 2 years ago

Comparing the maps (7m+tp, 7m, 7m pbcorr, tp) the 7m image (not corrected for pb) shows the clearest detection: ngc1385_comparison