assistant-ai / jess

9 stars 1 forks source link

As jess developer, I want to call log function from anywhere of the code, without transfering it as param. #110

Open nikkrichko opened 1 year ago

nikkrichko commented 1 year ago

User Story: As a Developer, I want to use Singleton for Logging

1. Persona and Role

Persona Description:

Importance of User Story for Persona:

As a software developer, John understands the significance of efficient logging for debugging and monitoring purposes. By utilizing the Singleton pattern for logging, John will be able to ensure that only one instance of the logging class is created throughout the application, allowing for centralized and consistent logging functionality. This user story is important for John as it helps him implement logging in a maintainable and scalable manner, saving time and effort in the long run.

2. Industry Best Practices

When implementing the Singleton pattern for logging, it is crucial to follow industry best practices for effective and robust code. Here are 10 best practices to consider:

  1. Ensure thread safety for concurrent access
  2. Implement lazy initialization for efficiency
  3. Use a private constructor to prevent external instantiation
  4. Provide a static instance variable for accessing the singleton object
  5. Apply synchronized access to the instance creation method
  6. Consider using an enum to implement the singleton
  7. Implement proper error handling and exception propagation
  8. Implement proper logging levels and log message formatting
  9. Consider using a logging framework or library for additional features
  10. Implement a clear and concise API for logging usage

3. INVEST Model

When applying the INVEST model to this user story, we can analyze it as follows:

4. Functionality or Improvement

The feature should bring the following functionality or improvements:

Sub-tasks for each functional requirement:

  1. Create a Singleton Logger class with a private constructor.
  2. Implement lazy initialization of the singleton instance.
  3. Provide a static method to access the singleton Logger instance.
  4. Implement logging methods for different log levels (e.g., debug, info, error).
  5. Allow customization of the logging level through configuration.
  6. Implement log message formatting based on the desired output format.
  7. Enable logging to different destinations by implementing appropriate handlers.
  8. Facilitate configuration of the log output destination (e.g., file path, database connection).
  9. Implement logic to capture and log contextual information or correlation IDs.
  10. Add support for logging stack traces for exceptions.
  11. Implement log rotation and file size management for efficient storage.
  12. Integrate with existing logging frameworks or libraries, if applicable.
  13. Establish thread-safety measures for concurrent access to the singleton logger instance.
  14. Enable logging in multi-threaded environments.
  15. Perform thorough unit testing and integration testing for all logging functionality.

5. Non-functional Requirements

The following non-functional requirements should be considered for this user story:

Sub-tasks for each non-functional requirement:

  1. Optimize the logging implementation to minimize performance impact.
  2. Measure and optimize the memory usage of the Singleton Logger class.
  3. Adhere to the company's coding style and naming conventions for the logging implementation.
  4. Choose a logging framework or library with good documentation and community support.
  5. Implement proper error handling and logging of error messages.
  6. Validate the logging performance for high-volume applications.
  7. Ensure modularity and code maintainability for future enhancements.
  8. Verify compatibility of the logging framework or library with the technology stack.
  9. Ensure the logging output is formatted and structured for easy readability and searchability.
  10. Validate compliance with security and privacy policies during the logging process.

6. Acceptance Criteria

To determine when the feature is complete and functioning correctly, the following acceptance criteria should be met:

  1. The Singleton Logger class can be instantiated only once throughout the application.
  2. The Singleton Logger class is thread-safe, allowing concurrent logging operations.
  3. The logging levels can be customized and effectively filter log messages.
  4. Log messages are accurately formatted based on the chosen output format.
  5. Log messages are successfully output to the desired destinations (e.g., console, file, database).
  6. Contextual information or correlation IDs are correctly logged and associated with relevant log messages.
  7. Stack traces are captured and logged for exceptions.
  8. Log rotation and file size management are working correctly without data loss.
  9. Integration with existing logging frameworks or libraries is successful, if applicable.
  10. The Singleton Logger class handles concurrent access in multi-threaded environments.
  11. Thorough unit tests cover all logging functionality, including different scenarios and log levels.
  12. Integration tests validate the logging behavior in a real application environment.
  13. The logging performance meets the required standards for the application.
  14. Proper error handling is implemented, and error log messages are generated when necessary.
  15. Compliance with security and privacy policies is ensured during the logging process.

Sub-tasks for each acceptance criteria:

  1. Implement logic to prevent multiple instances of the Singleton Logger class.
  2. Apply thread-safety mechanisms to the Singleton Logger class.
  3. Develop configuration options for logging levels and implement filtering logic.
  4. Implement log message formatting based on the chosen output format.
  5. Create handlers or adapters for each desired log destination.
  6. Capture and associate contextual information or correlation IDs with log messages.
  7. Implement logic to capture and log stack traces for exceptions.
  8. Develop log rotation and file size management functionality.
  9. Integrate with existing logging frameworks or libraries, if applicable.
  10. Ensure thread-safe access to the Singleton Logger class for concurrent environments.
  11. Create unit tests to cover all logging functionality and scenarios.
  12. Perform integration tests to validate the logging behavior in a real application.
  13. Measure and optimize the logging performance as needed.
  14. Implement error handling mechanisms and log error messages when appropriate.
  15. Conduct security and privacy checks during the logging process to ensure compliance.

7. Business Value

The feature of using Singleton for logging will bring the following benefits and value to users and the product:

8. Positive Test Cases

Here are examples of expected behavior and successful outcomes for thorough testing of the logging feature:

  1. Positive Test Case for Functional Requirement 1: Singleton Logger class instantiation

    • Input: Call the static method to obtain an instance of the Singleton Logger class.
    • Expected Output: The same instance is returned consistently.
  2. Positive Test Case for Functional Requirement 4: Log message at DEBUG level

    • Input: Call the logDebug() method with a debug message.
    • Expected Output: The debug message is logged with the DEBUG log level.
  3. Positive Test Case for Functional Requirement 8: Logging to a file

    • Input: Configure the Singleton Logger to output log messages to a specified file.
    • Expected Output: Log messages are correctly written to the specified file.
  4. Positive Test Case for Non-functional Requirement 4: Proper error handling and logging

    • Input: Invoke a method that generates an error or exception.
    • Expected Output: The error or exception is properly handled and logged.

Note: More positive test cases should be created to cover all functional and non-functional requirements.

9. Negative Test Cases

Specify scenarios where the feature should handle errors, edge cases, or unexpected inputs gracefully.

Note: More negative test cases should be created to cover potential error scenarios and edge cases.

10. Overview of Documentations

Documentation that should be created for this feature:

  1. User Guide: Provides an overview of the logging feature, installation steps, configuration options, and usage examples.
  2. Developer Guide: Explains the implementation details, class diagrams, API documentation, and integration instructions.
  3. Configuration Guide: Provides instructions for configuring the logging settings, including log level, output format, and destinations.
  4. Testing Guide: Describes the test scenarios, positive and negative test cases, and instructions for running the tests.
  5. Troubleshooting Guide: Offers solutions for common issues, error message explanations, and debugging tips.

11. Typical Bug and Pitfall

Developers should be aware of the following typical bugs and pitfalls when implementing Singleton for logging:

Top 10 Typical Bugs (Pitfalls) in this Area:

  1. Improper synchronization leading to multiple instances of the Singleton Logger class.
  2. Inefficient or incorrect handling of concurrent access to the logger instance.
  3. Inconsistent log levels or failure to properly filter log messages.
  4. Improper implementation of log message formatting, leading to incorrect output.
  5. Failure to handle and log contextual information or correlation IDs correctly.
  6. Incomplete or inconsistent log rotation and file size management.
  7. Incompatibility issues with existing logging frameworks or libraries.
  8. Lack of error handling for unexpected scenarios or exceptions.
  9. Insufficient testing and validation of the logging functionality.
  10. Violation of security and privacy policies during the logging process.

Recommendations on how to avoid them:

  1. Implement proper synchronization mechanisms, such as double-checked locking or the use of Enum.
  2. Use thread-safe constructs and techniques to handle concurrent access.
  3. Test and validate the log levels and filtering mechanisms thoroughly.
  4. Follow logging libraries' guidelines and best practices for log message formatting.
  5. Ensure correct association of contextual information or correlation IDs with log messages.
  6. Implement robust log rotation and file size management algorithms.
  7. Prioritize compatibility and test integrations with existing logging frameworks or libraries.
  8. Implement comprehensive error handling and appropriate error message logging.
  9. Write extensive unit tests and integration tests for the logging functionality.
  10. Strictly adhere to security and privacy policies during the logging process.
nikkrichko commented 1 year ago

@b0noI I think we need to include jess tldr for each user story that jess could generate :)