search

astrothesaurus / UAT

The Unified Astronomy Thesaurus is an open, interoperable and community-supported thesaurus of astronomical and astrophysical concepts and their relationships.
http://astrothesaurus.org/
Other
34 stars 13 forks source link

Clean up of sibling/ancestor pairs, submitted by Sarah Weissman (STScI) 8/11/2016 #5

Closed katieefrey closed 3 months ago

katieefrey commented 7 years ago

I also have a large-ish list of pairs of concepts that are both siblings and ancestors, e.g.: Galactic and extragalactic astronomy,Galaxy physics,Galaxy dynamics,,,,,,, Galactic and extragalactic astronomy,Galaxy physics,Galaxy processes,Galaxy dynamics,,,,,, I will attach the list but maybe we should start a Google doc somewhere and we can make it a group effort to fix these as we have time? Some of them are obvious how to fix, but not all. Just a thought. I'll let you decide!

See attached sibling-ancestor-pairs.txt

katieefrey commented 4 years ago

In cases where a concept is its direct aunt/uncle, I could see how they could be "fixed," but I hesitate to remove cases where the nesting goes deeper than that. Part of the point of the UAT is for concepts to exist in a poly hierarchy, for them to be found through multiple paths. I'm not sure we really need to clean up all the instances listed below.

I have used strikethrough to indicate the concept paths which have been eliminated via other updates to the UAT, and some comments in bold. Not a comprehensive assessment.

8/28/2020 - a few more of these have been resolved during other clean up efforts between originally posting this comment and now. I'm still unconvinced about the need to clean up all the instances listed below, but I would like to try to flag these for discussion if the relevant concepts are brought up in other issues.

==========

Galactic and extragalactic astronomy,Galaxy physics,Galaxy dynamics,,,,,,, Galactic and extragalactic astronomy,Galaxy physics,Galaxy processes,Galaxy dynamics,,,,,,

Stellar astronomy,Stellar types,Evolved stars,Giant stars,S stars,,,,, Stellar astronomy,Stellar types,Evolved stars,Giant stars,Late-type giants,Heavy metal stars,S stars,,,

Galactic and extragalactic astronomy,Galaxies,Quasar-galaxy pairs,,,,,,, Galactic and extragalactic astronomy,Galaxies,Active galaxies,Active galactic nuclei,Quasars,Quasar-galaxy pairs,,,,

Galactic and extragalactic astronomy,Galaxies,Radio jets,,,,,,, Galactic and extragalactic astronomy,Galaxies,Active galaxies,Active galactic nuclei,Radio jets,,,,,

Galactic and extragalactic astronomy,Galaxies,Starburst galaxies,,,,,,, Galactic and extragalactic astronomy,Galaxies,Active galaxies,Starburst galaxies,,,,,,

Solar system astronomy,Solar system,Oort cloud,,,,,,, Solar system astronomy,Solar system,Small solar system bodies,Comets,Long period comets,Oort cloud,,,,

Solar system astronomy,Solar system,The Moon,,,,,,, Solar system astronomy,Solar system,Natural satellites,The Moon,,,,,,

Solar system astronomy,Solar system,Meteors,,,,,,, Solar system astronomy,Solar system,Meteoroids,Meteors,,,,,,

Solar system astronomy,Planetary science,Planetary atmospheres,Atmospheric tides,,,,,, Solar system astronomy,Planetary science,Planetary atmospheres,Earth atmosphere,Atmospheric tides,,,,,

Solar system astronomy,Planetary science,Planetary atmospheres,Stratopause,,,,,, Solar system astronomy,Planetary science,Planetary atmospheres,Earth atmosphere,Stratopause,,,,,

Solar system astronomy,Planetary science,Planetary atmospheres,Water vapor,,,,,, Solar system astronomy,Planetary science,Planetary atmospheres,Earth atmosphere,Greenhouse gases,Water vapor,,,,

Stellar astronomy,Stellar types,Variable stars,Intrinsic variable stars,Pulsating variable stars,Beta Cephei stars,,,, Stellar astronomy,Stellar types,Variable stars,Intrinsic variable stars,Pulsating variable stars,Multi-periodic variable stars,Beta Cephei stars,,,

Stellar astronomy,Stellar types,Variable stars,Intrinsic variable stars,Pulsating variable stars,Double-mode variable stars,,,, Stellar astronomy,Stellar types,Variable stars,Intrinsic variable stars,Pulsating variable stars,Multi-periodic variable stars,Double-mode variable stars,,,

Stellar astronomy,Stellar types,Variable stars,Intrinsic variable stars,Pulsating variable stars,Delta Scuti variable stars,,,, Stellar astronomy,Stellar types,Variable stars,Intrinsic variable stars,Pulsating variable stars,Multi-periodic variable stars,Delta Scuti variable stars,,,

S Vulpeculae stars deprecated on September 13, 2018 12:39 PM Stellar astronomy,Stellar types,Variable stars,Intrinsic variable stars,Pulsating variable stars,S Vulpeculae stars,,,, Stellar astronomy,Stellar types,Variable stars,Intrinsic variable stars,Pulsating variable stars,Long period variable stars,S Vulpeculae stars,,,

Stellar astronomy,Stellar types,Variable stars,Intrinsic variable stars,Pulsating variable stars,Mira variable stars,,,, Stellar astronomy,Stellar types,Variable stars,Intrinsic variable stars,Pulsating variable stars,Long period variable stars,Mira variable stars,,,

Stellar astronomy,Stellar types,Novae,,,,,,, Stellar astronomy,Stellar types,Multiple stars,Binary stars,Close binary stars,Interacting binary stars,Semi-detached binary stars,Cataclysmic variable stars,Novae,,

Stellar astronomy,Stellar types,Novae,,,,,,, Stellar astronomy,Stellar types,Variable stars,Intrinsic variable stars,Cataclysmic variable stars,Novae,,,,

Stellar astronomy,Stellar remnants,Compact objects,Black holes,,,,,, Stellar astronomy,Stellar remnants,Compact objects,Compact binary systems,Compact binary components,Black holes,,,, (Maybe compact binary systems should be a sibling to Compact objects since a system is multiple objects, not an object?)

Stellar astronomy,Stellar remnants,Compact objects,Neutron stars,,,,,, Stellar astronomy,Stellar remnants,Compact objects,Compact binary systems,Compact binary components,Neutron stars,,,,

Astrophysical processes,Nuclear astrophysics,Nucleosynthesis,Helium burning,,,,,, Astrophysical processes,Nuclear astrophysics,Nucleosynthesis,Stellar nucleosynthesis,Helium burning,,,,,

Astrophysical processes,Nuclear astrophysics,Nucleosynthesis,Hydrogen burning,,,,,, Astrophysical processes,Nuclear astrophysics,Nucleosynthesis,Stellar nucleosynthesis,Hydrogen burning,,,,,

Observational astronomy,Techniques,Astrometry,Two-color diagrams,,,,,, Observational astronomy,Techniques,Astrometry,Magnitude,Apparent magnitude,Two-color diagrams,,,,

Solar astronomy,Sunspots,,,,,,,, Solar astronomy,Solar activity,Sunspots,,,,,,,

Solar astronomy,Solar flares,,,,,,,, Solar astronomy,Solar activity,Solar flares,,,,,,,

Cosmology,Origin of the universe,Big Bang theory,,,,,,, Cosmology,Big Bang theory,,,,,,,,

Interstellar medium,Supernova remnants,,,,,,,, Interstellar medium,Nebulae,Supernova remnants,,,,,,,

Stellar astronomy,Stellar types,Emission line stars,Z Andromedae stars,,,,,, Stellar astronomy,Stellar types,Emission line stars,Symbiotic binary stars,Z Andromedae stars,,,,,

Galactic and extragalactic astronomy,Galaxy physics,Galaxy structure,Radio cores,,,,,, Galactic and extragalactic astronomy,Galaxy physics,Galaxy structure,Galaxy components,Galaxy nuclei,Active galactic nuclei,Radio cores,,,

Gamma ray observatories might be on the ground Observational astronomy,Instrumentation,Observatories,Gamma-ray observatories,,,,,, Observational astronomy,Instrumentation,Observatories,Space observatories,Gamma-ray observatories,,,,,

Stellar astronomy,Stellar remnants,Compact objects,Compact binary systems,Cataclysmic variable stars,SX Arietis variables,,,, Stellar astronomy,Stellar remnants,Compact objects,Compact binary systems,Cataclysmic variable stars,Novae,Dwarf novae,SX Arietis variables,,

Stellar astronomy,Stellar remnants,Compact objects,Compact binary systems,Cataclysmic variable stars,Symbiotic novae,,,, Stellar astronomy,Stellar remnants,Compact objects,Compact binary systems,Cataclysmic variable stars,Novae,Symbiotic novae,,,

Galactic and extragalactic astronomy,Galaxies,Active galaxies,Blazars,,,,,, Galactic and extragalactic astronomy,Galaxies,Active galaxies,Active galactic nuclei,Blazars,,,,,

Observational astronomy,Instrumentation,Siderostats,,,,,,, Observational astronomy,Instrumentation,Stellar tracking devices,Siderostats,,,,,,

Stellar astronomy,Stellar types,Chemically peculiar stars,Am stars,,,,,, Stellar astronomy,Stellar types,Chemically peculiar stars,Magnetic stars,Magnetic variable stars,Am stars,,,,

Stellar astronomy,Stellar types,Chemically peculiar stars,Strontium stars,,,,,, Stellar astronomy,Stellar types,Chemically peculiar stars,Heavy metal stars,Strontium stars,,,,,

Stellar astronomy,Stellar types,Chemically peculiar stars,Technetium stars,,,,,, Stellar astronomy,Stellar types,Chemically peculiar stars,Heavy metal stars,Technetium stars,,,,,

Stellar astronomy,Stellar types,Chemically peculiar stars,Manganese stars,,,,,, Stellar astronomy,Stellar types,Chemically peculiar stars,Ap stars,Manganese stars,,,,,

Stellar astronomy,Stellar types,Chemically peculiar stars,Manganese stars,,,,,, Stellar astronomy,Stellar types,Chemically peculiar stars,Heavy metal stars,Manganese stars,,,,,

Stellar astronomy,Stellar types,Chemically peculiar stars,Bp stars,,,,,, Stellar astronomy,Stellar types,Chemically peculiar stars,Magnetic stars,Bp stars,,,,,

Stellar astronomy,Stellar types,Chemically peculiar stars,Mercury-manganese stars,,,,,, Stellar astronomy,Stellar types,Chemically peculiar stars,Magnetic stars,Mercury-manganese stars,,,,,

Solar system astronomy,Solar system,Meteoroids,Meteorites,Bediasites,,,,, Solar system astronomy,Solar system,Meteoroids,Meteorites,Tektites,Bediasites,,,,

Solar system astronomy,Solar system,Meteoroids,Meteorites,Moldavites,,,,, Solar system astronomy,Solar system,Meteoroids,Meteorites,Tektites,Moldavites,,,,

BartlettAstro commented 3 months ago

I am splitting this issue into individual issues so that we can deal with each pair as circumstances warrant.

Issue #368 Galactic and extragalactic astronomy,Galaxy physics,Galaxy dynamics,,,,,,, Galactic and extragalactic astronomy,Galaxy physics,Galaxy processes,Galaxy dynamics,,,,,,

Issue #369 Galactic and extragalactic astronomy,Galaxies,Quasar-galaxy pairs,,,,,,, Galactic and extragalactic astronomy,Galaxies,Active galaxies,Active galactic nuclei,Quasars,Quasar-galaxy pairs,,,,

Issue #370 Galactic and extragalactic astronomy,Galaxies,Radio jets,,,,,,, Galactic and extragalactic astronomy,Galaxies,Active galaxies,Active galactic nuclei,Radio jets,,,,,

Issute #371 Galactic and extragalactic astronomy,Galaxies,Starburst galaxies,,,,,,, Galactic and extragalactic astronomy,Galaxies,Active galaxies,Starburst galaxies,,,,,,

Issue #372 Solar system astronomy,Solar system,Oort cloud,,,,,,, Solar system astronomy,Solar system,Small solar system bodies,Comets,Long period comets,Oort cloud,,,,

Issue #373 Solar system astronomy,Solar system,The Moon,,,,,,, Solar system astronomy,Solar system,Natural satellites,The Moon,,,,,,

Issue #374 Solar system astronomy,Planetary science,Planetary atmospheres,Atmospheric tides,,,,,, Solar system astronomy,Planetary science,Planetary atmospheres,Earth atmosphere,Atmospheric tides,,,,,

Issue #375 Solar system astronomy,Planetary science,Planetary atmospheres,Stratopause,,,,,, Solar system astronomy,Planetary science,Planetary atmospheres,Earth atmosphere,Stratopause,,,,,

Issue #376 Solar system astronomy,Planetary science,Planetary atmospheres,Water vapor,,,,,, Solar system astronomy,Planetary science,Planetary atmospheres,Earth atmosphere,Greenhouse gases,Water vapor,,,,

Issue #377 Stellar astronomy,Stellar types,Variable stars,Intrinsic variable stars,Pulsating variable stars,Beta Cephei stars,,,, Stellar astronomy,Stellar types,Variable stars,Intrinsic variable stars,Pulsating variable stars,Multi-periodic variable stars,Beta Cephei stars,,,

Issue #378 Stellar astronomy,Stellar types,Variable stars,Intrinsic variable stars,Pulsating variable stars,Double-mode variable stars,,,, Stellar astronomy,Stellar types,Variable stars,Intrinsic variable stars,Pulsating variable stars,Multi-periodic variable stars,Double-mode variable stars,,,

Issue #379 Stellar astronomy,Stellar types,Variable stars,Intrinsic variable stars,Pulsating variable stars,Delta Scuti variable stars,,,, Stellar astronomy,Stellar types,Variable stars,Intrinsic variable stars,Pulsating variable stars,Multi-periodic variable stars,Delta Scuti variable stars,,,

Issue #380 Stellar astronomy,Stellar types,Variable stars,Intrinsic variable stars,Pulsating variable stars,Mira variable stars,,,, Stellar astronomy,Stellar types,Variable stars,Intrinsic variable stars,Pulsating variable stars,Long period variable stars,Mira variable stars,,,

Issue #381 Stellar astronomy,Stellar types,Novae,,,,,,, Stellar astronomy,Stellar types,Multiple stars,Binary stars,Close binary stars,Interacting binary stars,Semi-detached binary stars,Cataclysmic variable stars,Novae,,

Issues #382 Stellar astronomy,Stellar types,Novae,,,,,,, Stellar astronomy,Stellar types,Variable stars,Intrinsic variable stars,Cataclysmic variable stars,Novae,,,,

Issue #383 Astrophysical processes,Nuclear astrophysics,Nucleosynthesis,Hydrogen burning,,,,,, Astrophysical processes,Nuclear astrophysics,Nucleosynthesis,Stellar nucleosynthesis,Hydrogen burning,,,,,

Issue #384 Observational astronomy,Techniques,Astrometry,Two-color diagrams,,,,,, Observational astronomy,Techniques,Astrometry,Magnitude,Apparent magnitude,Two-color diagrams,,,,

Issue #385 Interstellar medium,Supernova remnants,,,,,,,, Interstellar medium,Nebulae,Supernova remnants,,,,,,,

Issue #386 Stellar astronomy,Stellar types,Emission line stars,Z Andromedae stars,,,,,, Stellar astronomy,Stellar types,Emission line stars,Symbiotic binary stars,Z Andromedae stars,,,,,

Issue #387 Observational astronomy,Instrumentation,Observatories,Gamma-ray observatories,,,,,, Observational astronomy,Instrumentation,Observatories,Space observatories,Gamma-ray observatories,,,,,

Issue #388 Stellar astronomy,Stellar remnants,Compact objects,Compact binary systems,Cataclysmic variable stars,SX Arietis variables,,,, Stellar astronomy,Stellar remnants,Compact objects,Compact binary systems,Cataclysmic variable stars,Novae,Dwarf novae,SX Arietis variables,,

Issue #389 Galactic and extragalactic astronomy,Galaxies,Active galaxies,Blazars,,,,,, Galactic and extragalactic astronomy,Galaxies,Active galaxies,Active galactic nuclei,Blazars,,,,,

Issue #390 Stellar astronomy,Stellar types,Chemically peculiar stars,Am stars,,,,,, Stellar astronomy,Stellar types,Chemically peculiar stars,Magnetic stars,Magnetic variable stars,Am stars,,,,

Issue #391 Stellar astronomy,Stellar types,Chemically peculiar stars,Strontium stars,,,,,, Stellar astronomy,Stellar types,Chemically peculiar stars,Heavy metal stars,Strontium stars,,,,,

Issue #392 Stellar astronomy,Stellar types,Chemically peculiar stars,Technetium stars,,,,,, Stellar astronomy,Stellar types,Chemically peculiar stars,Heavy metal stars,Technetium stars,,,,,

Issue #393 Stellar astronomy,Stellar types,Chemically peculiar stars,Manganese stars,,,,,, Stellar astronomy,Stellar types,Chemically peculiar stars,Ap stars,Manganese stars,,,,,

Stellar astronomy,Stellar types,Chemically peculiar stars,Manganese stars,,,,,, Stellar astronomy,Stellar types,Chemically peculiar stars,Heavy metal stars,Manganese stars,,,,,

Issue #394 Stellar astronomy,Stellar types,Chemically peculiar stars,Bp stars,,,,,, Stellar astronomy,Stellar types,Chemically peculiar stars,Magnetic stars,Bp stars,,,,,

Issue #395 Stellar astronomy,Stellar types,Chemically peculiar stars,Mercury-manganese stars,,,,,, Stellar astronomy,Stellar types,Chemically peculiar stars,Magnetic stars,Mercury-manganese stars,,,,,

BartlettAstro commented 3 months ago

All individual pairs listed here have either been resolved during release 5.0.0 (or earlier) or have transfered to their own issue for any further discussion.