search

asuiu / pyxtension

Pure Python extensions library that includes Scala-like streams, Json with attribute access syntax, and other common use stuff
MIT License
43 stars 1 forks source link

explicit agree on license changing #16

Open sergmain opened 2 years ago

sergmain commented 2 years ago

for changing from GPL to MIT type of licenses, the explicit agree from all contributors, including @asuiu @marian-rusu , must be collected

asuiu commented 2 years ago

for changing from GPL to MIT type of licenses, the explicit agree from all contributors, including @asuiu @marian-rusu , must be collected

@sergmain Why? For example - if one of the contributors is dead, the code-base can't change it's license anymore forever?

asuiu commented 2 years ago

Closed due to inactivity

sergmain commented 1 year ago

Sorry for necro, but for your case ' if one of the contributors is dead' the confirmation still required from heirs. there are a lot of legal cases which you can google or look at cases here - https://law.stackexchange.com/search?q=license

asuiu commented 1 year ago

@sergmain How this agreement is collected? The PR with the license change should be accepted by them, or there's another juridical procedure for this?

sergmain commented 1 year ago

If I'm not mistaken, at Jul 27, 2022 when I opened this ticket there were only 2 contributors with gpl license - you and @marian-rusu . If so, @marian-rusu can just post here that he agree to switch license. Otherwise you need to collect a list who was contributor to gpl-licensed code and ask everyone for confirmation.

asuiu commented 1 year ago

@sergmain

If I'm not mistaken, at Jul 27, 2022 when I opened this ticket there were only 2 contributors with gpl license - you and @marian-rusu . If so, @marian-rusu can just post here that he agree to switch license. Otherwise you need to collect a list who was contributor to gpl-licensed code and ask everyone for confirmation.

The word "here" is still ambiguous from the juridical point of view. Can you be more precise? Here - meaning this discussion thread? What is the formulation of agreement as well? is it enough just "agree" - or "agree with ...", and what are other aspects of proper agreement?

sergmain commented 1 year ago

The word "here" is still ambiguous from the juridical point of view. Can you be more precise? Here - meaning this discussion thread? What is the formulation of agreement as well? is it enough just "agree" - or "agree with ...", and what are other aspects of proper agreement?

Here - meaning this discussion thread? - yes What is the formulation of agreement as well? - something like that - https://cla.pivotal.io/