atuline / WLED

Control WS2812B and many more types of digital RGB LEDs with an ESP32 over WiFi.
GNU General Public License v3.0
864 stars 134 forks source link

Matrix modes seems to have a strange map, when using a stream to send something (ex. xLights) #205

Open lost-hope opened 2 years ago

lost-hope commented 2 years ago

I have a Matrix with WLed SR on it and wanted to try out xLights, to display text. The shown picture looked really strange. When switching the WLed back to Strip mode, it works as intended.

I would like to know or have a clear documentation about how the mapping of the streamed data should look like.

I already asked about this on Discord, but wanted it to add here, so i can be tracked easier. Answer of ewowi:

I worked last year on the 2D effects, but only on build-in effects to 2D matrix (function xy and logical2physical), not on e1.31, so might well be this is an untouched area ready for improvement. embedded-creations , any idea if there is some system or regularity currently or it is just an open area to be improved?

dosipod commented 2 years ago

We did a lot of testing before with xlights and srwled and there is a lot combinations settings in xlights and wled that could impact how the effects are displayed .

It might help if you provide more info on your setup and if you want us to replicate your issue then please provide more details on how did you setup e1.31 and universes in xlights and your matrix info as I am not sure of the size but we have multiple 16x16 and 8x32 matrices so hopefully we could match your setup

lost-hope commented 2 years ago

So this is my physical led Layout. image

In WLED my Matrix settings are:

2D Matrix Width: 32 Height: 32 2D Panel Horizontal Panels: 1 Vertical Panels: 4 2D Panel Layout Firstled Position: Bottom Right Orientation: Vertical Serpentine: true Transpose: false

The 2D Panel Layout looks not correct when comparing the picture above and the position of the first Led, but this is the only way i get a picture with it.

My DMX Settings: image

In xLights i have just set up a controller and tried different models.

When using the single line you can really see the unusual Layout (also in the Peek on the WLED web gui). I can try to make a video of it later.

dosipod commented 2 years ago

Some of the guys reported that xlights worked with those flexible matrices better if in wled led setting ( Serpentine is not checked ) .The matrix effects will not look good on its own but will be okay when used with xlights .

I do not have a setup for 32x32 but tested with 16x32 ( two 16x16) .

netmindz commented 2 years ago

Possibly related to https://github.com/atuline/WLED/issues/175