search

auth0 / auth0-java-mvc-common

Contains common helper classes and api client logic that are used across our Java MVC libraries
MIT License
43 stars 39 forks source link

Library does not work with recent Servlet containers #111

Open uap-universe opened 2 years ago

uap-universe commented 2 years ago

Describe the problem you'd like to have solved

The library does not work with recent Servlet containers that implement Jakarta EE.

Describe the ideal solution

A new major version of this library should be made available, that depends on jakarta.servlet instead of javax.servlet.

Whoever wants to use Java EE Servlet containers, can rely on the current major version of this library.

Alternatives and current work-arounds

Currently there does not seem to be an alternative in the com.auth0 group that could be used as a replacement for this library.

Additional information, if any

Jakarta EE was released more than two years ago and is broadly adopted.

Relates to #97

jimmyjames commented 2 years ago

👋 Thanks for raising @uap-universe! I agree that a new major should be made available, which would (among other things) target Jakarta EE (will need to decide which version to target, likely 9.1). We do have plans for a new major version; it will likely be 2023 as first we are going to make a new major of auth0-java. Thanks again!

stale[bot] commented 1 year ago

This issue has been automatically marked as stale because it has not had recent activity. It will be closed if no further activity occurs. If you have not received a response for our team (apologies for the delay) and this is still a blocker, please reply with additional information or just a ping. Thank you for your contribution! 🙇‍♂️

sethcrothers commented 1 year ago

Also chiming in requesting support for the new version(s) of the Java servlet spec, specifically 5.0 which changes javax.servlet. to jakarta.servlet..

javad-md commented 1 year ago

We also require support for the updated servlet spec - any update on this?

teefal commented 1 year ago

Also would like this as well. Even just s/javax/jakarta :)

siropa commented 1 year ago

Any update for this? Need this in order to use with tomcat 10

McCul commented 1 year ago

Any update ?

marvec commented 1 year ago

Still nothing?

rvinzent commented 9 months ago

@jimmyjames This issue is now well over a year old, are there any updates on a timeline here? It's starting to be a blocking dependency to upgrading other projects to LTS versions

uap-universe commented 9 months ago

It's over four years now, that Jakarta EE has been released, if I might add. The first versions of Tomcat that migrated to Jakarta EE are already end of life.

rvinzent commented 7 months ago

We do have plans for a new major version; it will likely be 2023 as first we are going to make a new major of auth0-java

@jimmyjames any updates as we enter the second quarter of 2024? If the update is "we're not going to maintain this anymore, please move on", can you please just let us know so we can figure out another solution?

lakshyabatman commented 2 weeks ago

I guess we have to move on? Folks have you figured out a way to handle this ?

I was thinking to make an adapter.

cowwoc commented 1 week ago

Honestly, don't bother. This library is dead. I ended up writing my own implementation for the REST API methods I needed, and it works just fine. auth0 should pull this library to stop wasting people's time.

uap-universe commented 1 week ago

I guess we have to move on? Folks have you figured out a way to handle this ?

Yes, I removed it - and the entire Okta SSO solution - from my application. But I see this is not an easy step for everyone.