search

autotyp / autotyp-data

AUTOTYP data export
Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International
38 stars 20 forks source link

Multiple geographic locations #5

Closed bambooforest closed 7 years ago

bambooforest commented 7 years ago

Some data points in the Register have multiple geographic locations:

indo1316 -- Eurasia vs Pacific (Indonesian) oira1263 -- Pacific vs Eurasia (Oirata; Indonesia)

which seem ok, but these two seem weird:

kyer1238 -- Eurasia vs Africa (Kyerung; Nepal) kati1270 -- Eurasia vs Pacific (Afghanistan / Pakistan)

Perhaps wrong Glottolog code assignment?

tzakharko commented 7 years ago

Fixed in the database, will be exported with the next incremental release.

HedvigS commented 5 years ago

I found some more, in register.csv the following languoids have more than one Area associated with them: ‘balk1252’, ‘east2295’, ‘indo1316’, ‘kati1270’, ‘kyer1238’, ‘mart1256’, ‘minn1241’, ‘noga1249’, ‘oira1263’, ‘peri1253’, ‘taha1241’, ‘tibe1272’, ‘till1254’, ‘toho1245’

Sometimes the long/lat are also widely different, as in 'kati1270'.

glottocode Area longitude latitude
kati1270 Indic 70.00 35.50
kati1270 S New Guinea 140.92 -5.75

Several of these could be cases of wrong glottocode assignment.

balthasarbickel commented 5 years ago

Thanks!

Balthasar.

On 27 Feb 2019, at 06:00, Hedvig Skirgård notifications@github.com wrote:

I found some more, in register.csv the following languoids have more than one Area associated with them: ‘balk1252’, ‘east2295’, ‘indo1316’, ‘kati1270’, ‘kyer1238’, ‘mart1256’, ‘minn1241’, ‘noga1249’, ‘oira1263’, ‘peri1253’, ‘taha1241’, ‘tibe1272’, ‘till1254’, ‘toho1245’

Sometimes the long/lat are also widely different, as in 'kati1270'.

glottocode Area longitude latitude kati1270 Indic 70.00 35.50 kati1270 S New Guinea 140.92 -5.75 — You are receiving this because you were assigned. Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub, or mute the thread.