search

awesome-davian / awesome-reviews-kaist

Computer vision paper reviews written by KAIST AI students
Creative Commons Attribution Share Alike 4.0 International
43 stars 118 forks source link

[2022 Spring] CVRP 2022 CLIP-NeRF[Eng] (20223186) #491

Open MaheZ20Kaist opened 2 years ago

MaheZ20Kaist commented 2 years ago

Great review, everything seems to be in line with instructions. Good formatting. There seems to be a spelling error in 'CLIP' section. I believe it would be 'Given'. The introduction section needs more elaboration since it has a few technical terms. As a background an overview of the approaches in NeRF ECCV'20 and CLIP(ICML 21) may be discussed.

enver1323 commented 2 years ago

Fantastic review. I only noticed couple of typos:

  1. In the "Motivation -> classical volume rendering" paragraph after the formula the span is given (... from $r(tn)$ to $r(tn)$
  2. In the "Motivation -> CLIP" paragraph, it is written (... web pages like Wekipedia ...)
  3. In the "Experiment Details -> Implementation details" there is pre-last bullet "Tthey"

I really enjoyed reading this review. Great amount of effort was put to produce tremendous output.

xwa15 commented 2 years ago

Thank you very much for your awesome review. This review is well-organized and easy to understand. The related work is so detailed that it not only introduces the CLIP-NeRF proposed in this paper, but also introduces its combination of NeRF and CLIP method. This makes the motivation of CLIP-NeRF very clear. The method and results part are also very fascinating.