Add guix-forge - Githubissues

jgarte commented 1 year ago

name: "guix-forge"
website_url: "https://guix-forge.systemreboot.net/manual/dev/en/"
source_code_url: "https://git.systemreboot.net/guix-forge/"
description: "guix-forge is a Guix service that lets you run a complete software forge in the manner of GitHub"
licenses:
  - GPLv3+
platforms:
  - Scheme
tags:
  - Automation
depends_3rdparty: no
demo_url: https://archive.org/details/arun-isaac-on-guix-forge

To ensure your issue is dealt with swiftly, please check the following (check the boxes [x]):

[x ] Submit one item per pull issue. This eases reviewing and speeds up inclusion.
[x ] You have searched the repository for any relevant issues or PRs, including closed ones.
[x ] Any software you are adding is not already listed at any of awesome-sysadmin, staticgen.com, staticsitegenerators.net, dbdb.io.
[x ] Any software project you are adding to the list is actively maintained.
[x ] Any software project you are adding was first released more than 4 months ago.
[x ] Any software project you are adding has working installation instructions.
[ x] If you are adding software forked from another active project, please provide/link to a clear list of differences between both.

kokomo123 commented 1 year ago

Regarding the demo being on the Internet Archive that's just a video, could you consider moving it to an actual demo of the software on your website? If that's not feasible, then that's fine. other then that, I looked through and couldn't seem to find a stable release. only the repository itself has a release nor there's a web ui, only CLI. Is there a stable tag, etc for the user to use instead of having to pull from the main branch everytime? Considering these questions, i shall await a response. Thanks

arunisaac commented 1 year ago

Hi there! I am the maintainer of the guix-forge project. Thanks, @jgarte, for contributing it to awesome-selfhosted!

I could embed the Internet Archive video in the guix-forge home page. Would that help?

About releases: guix-forge is a channel for GNU Guix. See https://guix.gnu.org/manual/en/html_node/Channels.html Guix channels don't usually have releases or tags, and it is customary for users to pull from the main branch everytime using guix pull.

arunisaac commented 1 year ago

Also, guix-forge is a CLI tool. It is meant to install and maintain (on your self-hosted server) other tools such as laminar CI, cgit, etc. that come with a web UI.

kokomo123 commented 1 year ago

@nodiscc what do you think of this? Thanks for responding by the way arun!

kokomo123 commented 1 year ago

Hi there! I am the maintainer of the guix-forge project. Thanks, @jgarte, for contributing it to awesome-selfhosted!

I could embed the Internet Archive video in the guix-forge home page. Would that help?

About releases: guix-forge is a channel for GNU Guix. See https://guix.gnu.org/manual/en/html_node/Channels.html Guix channels don't usually have releases or tags, and it is customary for users to pull from the main branch everytime using guix pull.

I meant, is there a plan to create a demo like laminar CI, cgit, etc for people to try out before installing on their own devices? sorta like other FOSS software that's time based or limited in functionality. ~~Also embedding the video will definitely help instead of a outside source so it's clear and center.~~

Ki-er commented 1 year ago

I cant remember where the source is however demos should be interactive. Not videos.

Therefore the video demo should be removed.

nodiscc commented 1 year ago

don't usually have releases or tags, and it is customary for users to pull from the main branch everytime

:confused: terrible practice for multiple reasons (no warning for breaking changes, software changing behavior on upgrades without admin approval, etc).

The first commit dates back to 2021 but there is no way to know which version is the first "usable/working" one. I think the best course of action, is to tag the current version as 1.0.0 and wait for 4 months before submitting it.

demos should be interactive.

This is correct, we used to have this guideline written down in https://github.com/awesome-selfhosted/awesome-selfhosted but I can't find it here. https://github.com/awesome-selfhosted/awesome-selfhosted/blob/ae5aa43f54f46e75ed522a065d3133401ed736b2/.github/PULL_REQUEST_TEMPLATE.md

demo links should only be used for interactive demos, i.e. not video demonstrations.

If someone wants to take the time to add it back to https://github.com/awesome-selfhosted/awesome-selfhosted-data/blob/master/.github/PULL_REQUEST_TEMPLATE.md it would be appreciated.

arunisaac commented 1 year ago

:confused: terrible practice for multiple reasons (no warning for breaking changes, software changing behavior on upgrades without admin approval, etc).

The first commit dates back to 2021 but there is no way to know which version is the first "usable/working" one. I think the best course of action, is to tag the current version as 1.0.0 and wait for 4 months before submitting it.

Your point is well taken. But, guix-forge is a Guix channel, not regular software with tagged releases and release tarballs. Users of Guix channels don't usually download specific tagged releases. They run a guix pull and expect to get the latest.

Nevertheless, I see your point. Some users may benefit from having more stable tagged releases. So, I have now started using them. To start with, here's a v0.1.0 tag: https://git.systemreboot.net/guix-forge/tag/?h=v0.1.0

demos should be interactive.

As of this moment, guix-forge does not have any demo instances with dummy data. But, there are two real world instances of guix-forge:

systemreboot.net:

genenetwork.org:

The above laminar and cgit instances are managed by guix-forge. But, it is hard/impossible to tell simply by looking at these pages. There is no branding or landing page as such. Perhaps in the future.

Ki-er commented 1 year ago

To be revisited: 5 February 2024

awesome-selfhosted / awesome-selfhosted-data

Add guix-forge #226