Weekly Unmaintained Project Check (Week of 21.12.15)

Kickball commented 8 years ago

Below is a list of projects which have had no code changes in the last 6 months on Github:

[x] chyrp - works as expected
[x] myyna - abandoned
[x] scuttle - some forks https://github.com/makoshark/scuttle/network
[x] newebe - removed but seems to work as expected
[x] Baun - apparently maintained
[x] OpenEats 2015, active fork at https://github.com/RyanNoelk/OpenEats
[x] daloradius - maintained https://github.com/lirantal/daloradius/commits/master
[x] CacoCloud 2015
[x] Creaky-Coot - seems to work as expected, simple
[x] leselys - development restarted
[x] lite-reader - development restarted
[x] Readr - removed in 7d27b53a7a1c19c93dc5d5fb81ecfd00a0cbc425
[x] rssminer - removed in 7d27b53a7a1c19c93dc5d5fb81ecfd00a0cbc425
[x] ttrss-mobile - works as expected, simple
[x] gritttt-rss - updated Sep 2016, works as expected, simple
[x] Apaxy - works as expected, simple
[x] MediaCrush -> Remove #1014
[x] FileTea -> Remove #1014
[x] sharefest -> Remove #1014
[x] 20euros -> simple, works as expected
[x] Cubiks-2048 -> simple, works as expected
[x] mindmaps -> https://github.com/nielinjie/mindmaps
[x] jotter -> Remove #1014
[x] minimalist-web-notepad - works as expected, simple
[x] notes -> maintained, simple enough, seems to work as expected
[x] cryptonote -> maintained, simple enough, seems to work as expected
[x] haste-server
[x] pastedown -> Remove #1014
[x] Reportr/dashboard -> Remove #1014
[x] gallery3 - unmaintained http://galleryproject.org/
[x] phog removed in d39b29ba21b9c5c0832d1c6836de4016911b5257
[x] PhotoLight, simple codebase, works as expected, no major issues
[x] pygmyfoto removed d39b29ba21b9c5c0832d1c6836de4016911b5257
[ ] Shot.io abandoned 2014 -> Remove
[x] Kyela maintained 2017
[x] OpenSondage maintained in fork
[ ] scotty unmaintained, complex code (java), security component -> Remove
[x] OranjeProxy seems to work in most cases, simple codebase (704 lines of PHP)
[ ] readityourself - unmaintained, doesn't work anymore, remove
[x] pairjam unmaintained
[ ] docstore (see below), seems to work as expected but was removed in 0e7238a59b2074640f9bf5907e05c66f95f5fa36. Now under BSD license -> re-add it
[x] markdown-tree - works as expected, simple
[ ] bulldog 2017-04-04 see below, waiting for maintainer reply
[x] tasks.php simple code, low maintenance, no major problems https://github.com/Kickball/awesome-selfhosted/pull/969
[x] tinyissue unmaintained, removed
[x] Bumpy-Booby - works as expected, simple
[ ] gaskit maintainer reply below: unmaintained, unknown working state -> Remove
[x] blazekiss 1000 lines of PHP, seems to work as expected -> Keep it in the list
[x] commonplace 280 lines of ruby, dependencies can be updated through bundle install
[ ] gruik README.md states abandoned project -> Remove
[x] olelo, maintainer active, seems to work as expected -> Keep
[ ] Wikitten, unmaintained, security-related bugs -> Remove

Kickball commented 8 years ago

@nodiscc there are a lot of unmaintained projects to tackle!

nodiscc commented 8 years ago

Nice work. What should we do with these projects? I use a few of them (chyrp, ttrss-mobile, OpenSondage...) and they are working fine. Development inactivity might be due to the fact that they have reached maturity and only need a few fixes every so often. Some projects are really simple (eg. 20euros) and also do not need constant development/maintenance.

nodiscc commented 8 years ago

I have ticked projects that I think should be kept in the list (simple/stable/complete, or for which there are no up-to-date alternatives, I use some of them). Anyone, please let us know if you are still using one of these programs.

A symbol could be added to low-maintenance/discontinued but working projects ☒

@Kickball @AndyR207 Or can we experiment with tuning the inactivity delay? Are you OK to share the detection script? This can help deciding what should be done with https://github.com/Kickball/awesome-selfhosted/issues/378 (automated checks/builds in some way)

BTW OpenSondage is now https://git.framasoft.org/framasoft/framadate

Happy new year people

Kickball commented 8 years ago

My apologies for not getting back to you about this, the holidays have been a busy period for me.

For now what you have done works well.

I've uploaded the script to a (for now) private repo which you have been added to, we will work on the script there.

Happy new year! :)

nodiscc commented 8 years ago

[x] Pairjam seems to be abandoned. The main website is down. No active forks. No commits since 2014. I vote for removal

Kickball: Removed in #468.

nodiscc commented 8 years ago

[x] Tinyissue has an active fork at https://github.com/satrun77/tinyissue

Kickball: Updated in #467.

nodiscc commented 8 years ago

A symbol could be added to low-maintenance/discontinued but working projects ☒

[x] Is this ok?

arylatt commented 8 years ago

@nodiscc looks good to me.

Kickball commented 8 years ago

@nodiscc a symbol for non-maintained but functioning projects sounds like a good idea to me.

nodiscc commented 8 years ago

~~[ ] Active fork of https://github.com/drichard/mindmaps -> https://github.com/nielinjie/mindmaps~~ inactive

nodiscc commented 8 years ago

Work started in branch https://github.com/Kickball/awesome-selfhosted/tree/rm-unmaintained-381

Kickball commented 8 years ago

Closing for now as we will be getting an updated list with the new system within a few weeks.

nodiscc commented 7 years ago

@Kickball @arylatt Any updates on the new validation system?

I will reopen this and work on removing/checking remaining projects.

nodiscc commented 7 years ago

https://github.com/nhoening/gritttt-rss was updated recently (Sep 2016) and looks simple enough to not require heavy maintenance

github.com/AlDanial/cloc v 1.70  T=0.13 s (186.6 files/s, 19437.7 lines/s)
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Language                     files          blank        comment           code
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
CSS                              5            112            162            968
JavaScript                       7             62            131            426
Python                           1             26             12            147
PHP                              3             17             16            120
HTML                             2             13              0            115
Markdown                         4             37              0             67
XSLT                             1              8              0             55
SQL                              1              0              4              2
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
SUM:                            24            275            325           1900
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------

https://github.com/SSilence/notes was updated Apr 2016 and looks simple enough to be kept (single PHP file + TinyMCE)

github.com/AlDanial/cloc v 1.70  T=0.36 s (175.9 files/s, 3903.6 lines/s)
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Language                     files          blank        comment           code
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
CSS                             11            136             29            693
HTML                             2            117              0            263
PHP                              1             15              0             91
JavaScript                      48              0              2             62
Markdown                         2              3              0              9
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
SUM:                            64            271             31           1118
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------

https://github.com/alainmeier/cryptonote dependencies were updated Aug 2016, no grave issue has been reported, code looks simple enough to be kept as-is

github.com/AlDanial/cloc v 1.70  T=0.23 s (241.8 files/s, 7397.3 lines/s)
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Language                     files          blank        comment           code
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
SASS                             5             99              3            401
JavaScript                       3             45             58            260
Ruby                            33            100            194            241
Slim                            10             16              0            125
Markdown                         2             36              0             74
YAML                             2              4             37             14
JSON                             1              0              0              6
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
SUM:                            56            300            292           1121
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------

nodiscc commented 7 years ago

Removed in #1014

MediaCrush, Filetea, ShareFest, Jotter: development stopped, noticeable reported issues, no active forks. I will submit a patch to remove these. Pastedown: unmaintained, 71648 lines of code. Reportr: unmaintained, noticeable issues, website is down.

nodiscc commented 7 years ago

20euros, Cubiks-2048: unmaintained but simple enough to be kept

OpenEats: apparently maintained fork https://github.com/RyanNoelk/OpenEats

nodiscc commented 7 years ago

https://github.com/thibaud-rohmer/PhotoLight is simple enough to be kept and has no reported major issues (single-file PHP app)
https://github.com/AliasIO/Shot.io development stopped in 2014, README still states "work in progress", homepage down, domain changed owner. -> Remove
Kyela: currently maintained
Readityourself: currently broken, unmaintained (2014) -> Remove
- Scotty: unmaintained, complex code (java), security component -> Remove
- OranjeProxy: seems to work in most cases, simple codebase (704 lines of PHP)

nodiscc commented 7 years ago

https://github.com/haldean/docstore/: client-side javascript only, dependencies in libs/ are outdated but could be easily updated (npm/git submodules) -> Keep it? Ping @haldean is docstore still in a working state? What can be done about out-of-date dependencies?

https://github.com/infews/bulldog/: client-side javascript only, but requires building it from source + dependencies are outdated + travis tests currently fail -> Remove? (though there is an old release of a static single-file HTML version on the Releases page) @infews is bulldog still in a working state? What can be done about out-of-date dependencies?

nodiscc commented 7 years ago

https://github.com/RaymiiOrg/tasks.php: simple codebase, no major issues -> Keep (see https://github.com/Kickball/awesome-selfhosted/pull/969)

https://github.com/bkeepers/gaskit/: unmaintained since 2012, 614 lines of ruby, 239 lines of custom Javascript. Dependencies (spine, handlebars, jquery) are highly outdated -> Remove it from the list? @bkeepers is gaskit still in a working state? What can be done to update dependencies?

nodiscc commented 7 years ago

https://github.com/ldleman/blazekiss: 1000 lines of PHP, seems to work as expected -> Keep it in the list

https://github.com/fredoliveira/commonplace: 280 lines of ruby, dependencies can be updated through bundle install -> Keep it in the list (homepage is down though)

haldean commented 7 years ago

re: haldean/docstore: It is still very much in a usable state, but I consider it "done" and have no plans to update it. Due to what appears to be some interest (to be honest, I have no idea what this thread is) I just added a BSD license; if people feel a need to update the libraries in it or fork it they're more than welcome to.

bkeepers commented 7 years ago

@bkeepers is gaskit still in a working state? What can be done to update dependencies?

I don't know. I am not working on it and do not know anyone using it in production.

nodiscc commented 7 years ago

Thanks @haldean @bkeepers for your replies

Apologies for the random @-mention, this issue is about removing unmaintained projects from https://github.com/Kickball/awesome-selfhosted (take a look if you have time, hope you will find it useful).

^{by the way docstore was removed in https://github.com/Kickball/awesome-selfhosted/commit/0e7238a59b2074640f9bf5907e05c66f95f5fa36 due to missing license/no reply; but since I used/liked it back in the day and you stated it is functional and can be considered complete I will re add it}

awesome-selfhosted / awesome-selfhosted

Weekly Unmaintained Project Check (Week of 21.12.15) #381