search

aws / amazon-ecs-init

Amazon Elastic Container Service RPM
http://aws.amazon.com/ecs
Apache License 2.0
198 stars 119 forks source link

[Proposal] Integrate ECS Init into ECS Agent & deprecate standalone ECS Init repository #482

Open fierlion opened 2 years ago

fierlion commented 2 years ago

The ECS team is planning on merging ECS Init and its related components into https://github.com/aws/amazon-ecs-agent and deprecating the standalone https://github.com/aws/amazon-ecs-init repository.

We would like comments on: How the proposed changes will affect your use case.

Problem Statement

Presently we have separate repositories for the Amazon ECS Agent and for ECS Init. The separation requires us to maintain build synchronization mechanisms to require the ECS Agent Image as a prerequisite to the RPM/DEB targets included in ECS Init’s Makefile. This separation forces a more complicated build process which inhibits us from taking full advantage of the software that builds rpm/deb packages (for example see: https://fedoraproject.org/wiki/Koji).

Standalone Repository Deprecation - ECS Init

To streamline and unify our build process, we plan on merging ECS Init and its related components into the ECS Agent repository. We will be augmenting the ECS Agent Makefile with all existing ECS Init targets, (as well as adding a few more targets to facilitate neater end-to-end builds.) The updated process will allow us to create our rpm/deb build targets without dependencies on external/separate ECS Agent image builds. It will simplify the overall code and will make testing ECS Init with ECS Agent more manageable.

The merge of ECS Init into ECS Agent will include the full commit history. In the near term, we will still be actively updating the ECS Init repository as well as updating the ECS Init code inside the ECS Agent repository.

We are not proposing that ECS Init itself will be deprecated, rather that the standalone repository which encapsulates the ECS Init functionality will be deprecated and ECS Init and all its related components will be integrated into the ECS Agent repository.

kixorz commented 1 year ago

Is this process now completed? If so, can you perhaps consider deleting this repository?

Realmonia commented 1 year ago

Hi @kixorz , yeah this process is completed and you can find ecs-init related make target and code in ecs-agent repo.

There are several steps for us to do before we archive this repo. The work is in progress.

kixorz commented 1 year ago

Thank you.