az0 / linkgopher

Firefox/Google Chrome add-on: Extracts all links from web page, sorts them, removes duplicates, and displays them in a new tab for inspection or copy and paste into other systems.
GNU General Public License v3.0
257 stars 56 forks source link

The new design breaks the simple premise of the tool #70

Closed ringofyre closed 8 months ago

ringofyre commented 8 months ago

which is to be able to copy links as texts.

Sorry - this is a tool I've used for years and now it's literally useless.

az0 commented 8 months ago

On Mozilla, I disabled Link Gopher version 2.6.1, which makes version 2.5.0 the primary version. I assume it will not downgrade you, so you may need to reinstall. Let me know how it goes.

rvbtnks commented 8 months ago

which is to be able to copy links as texts.

Sorry - this is a tool I've used for years and now it's literally useless.

i'm sure the intent was well, but yeah...the extension worked perfect for what i needed before.

the only reason i'm on the github is to try to go back to the previous version

ringofyre commented 8 months ago

On Mozilla, I disabled Link Gopher version 2.6.1, which makes version 2.5.0 the primary version. I assume it will not downgrade you, so you may need to reinstall. Let me know how it goes.

Thank you - I've dld the 2.50 xpi from Mozilla "Previous Ver.", removed 2.61 and disabled automatic updates. & can confirm that it works.

I think a fresh look is great and the design was not unattractive but don't fuck with the formatting - for those of us on os's that a strict on line breaks etc. (linux, commandline) adding a space between lines is just extra steps.

mollyrealized commented 8 months ago

Respectfully, +1. Grateful for this extension but really, really disliked the new design. Keep it as is.

az0 commented 8 months ago

@mharris1319 Were you able to find your way back to version 2.5.0?

mollyrealized commented 8 months ago

Yes, thank you, afterwards I left that comment.

DH-LStudios commented 8 months ago

On Mozilla, I disabled Link Gopher version 2.6.1, which makes version 2.5.0 the primary version. I assume it will not downgrade you, so you may need to reinstall. Let me know how it goes.

Thank you - I've dld the 2.50 xpi from Mozilla "Previous Ver.", removed 2.61 and disabled automatic updates. & can confirm that it works.

I think a fresh look is great and the design was not unattractive but don't fuck with the formatting

@ringofyre

I deeply apologize. I designed the layout, and I messed up big time by not considering how other's beyond myself were using it, especially with other OS's, as you pointed out, that all slipped my mind, and I'm extremely sorry for messing up. I just want to make sure that you know that the fault lies with me, and not with @az0, and again I apologize.

az0 commented 8 months ago

Next time I will test these cases more carefully.

mollyrealized commented 8 months ago

I hope you do not mind me reopening this just to say to @az0 and to @Labryn: you are very much appreciated. Your work is very much appreciated.

@az0, this is a fantastic extension that I find myself using daily to efficiently pull links from certain pages that otherwise don't permit it (TikTok favorites, Reddit saves, etc.). Do you have a Ko-Fi or something? For the amount of use I give this thing I should at least buy you the Ko-Fi equivalent of a pizza or something.

And @Labryn, I have had ideas before that I thought were wonderful and efficient and great, and when they hit the light of day with other people, I got my a** handed back to me, so that sort of experience of misalignment is by no means unique to you. UI is always a learning experience and a changing target and even huge companies get it completely wrong sometime.

I just frankly don't want either of you to walk away feeling bad about this. This is a great extension -- and @Labryn even if this particular redesign didn't work, you wanted to contribute towards making something better, and that's an admirable motivation.

DH-LStudios commented 8 months ago

I hope you do not mind me reopening this just to say to @az0 and to @Labryn: you are very much appreciated. Your work is very much appreciated.

@az0, this is a fantastic extension that I find myself using daily to efficiently pull links from certain pages that otherwise don't permit it (TikTok favorites, Reddit saves, etc.). Do you have a Ko-Fi or something? For the amount of use I give this thing I should at least buy you the Ko-Fi equivalent of a pizza or something.

And @Labryn, I have had ideas before that I thought were wonderful and efficient and great, and when they hit the light of day with other people, I got my a** handed back to me, so that sort of experience of misalignment is by no means unique to you. UI is always a learning experience and a changing target and even huge companies get it completely wrong sometime.

I just frankly don't want either of you to walk away feeling bad about this. This is a great extension -- and @Labryn even if this particular redesign didn't work, you wanted to contribute towards making something better, and that's an admirable motivation.

Thank you so much! @az0 should take all the credit. He's the genius behind the extension. I actually was just going to do a dark mode privately for myself until I saw someone else ask or it, but @az0 is a good guy and was thinking about the whole picture, his sweet extension, and everyone who uses it, and I can tell he just wants whoever uses Link Gopher to be satisfied and happy which is great.

I had a few ideas like having a button or icon that would allow anyone to copy all the links without any crazy layout. The format could stay the same but for those wanting a very plain list to reference, it would be quick and efficient, at least IMHO. Then I wanted to have an export function with several options for the rendered output. Whether it be plain text, a spreadsheet, a simple PDF, etc..

Wow sorry I didn't mean to ramble. But I really appreciate it, and while I may be kicking myself, I believe @az0 is going to make the extension awesome and I just hope that everyone who discovers and uses it realizes that he put a lot of work into it.