LBRS Urok Doomhowl encounter issues

Shineslippers commented 2 years ago

What client do you play on?

enUS

Faction

[X] Alliance
[X] Horde

Content Phase:

[ ] Generic
[ ] 1-19
[ ] 20-29
[ ] 30-39
[ ] 40-49
[X] 50-59

Current Behaviour

Urok Doomhowl, Urok's Tribute Pile, Roughshod Pike, Omokk's Head

The mobs don't attack the Pike with Head
The boss is despawning after appear
Urok's Tribute Pile with Pike and Head doesn't disapear

Expected Blizzlike Behaviour

The mobs should attack the pike if there is no players around
The boss should not despawning after summon
Urok's Tribute Pile with Pike and Head should disapear after Urok appear

Source

Wowhead Urok Doomhowl:

By Xenomech on 2008/09/10 (Patch 3.0.1) If you wipe after planting the head on the pike, you don't get a second chance. You'll have to get the head and pike and try all over again.

By 146568 on 2008/10/26 (Patch 3.0.2) If you wipe while fighting Urok himself, he'll stay there. So you can wipe safely after the waves of ogres, killing urok later.

By TwoGlassEyes on 2008/11/01 (Patch 3.0.2) Also important to note, if you let the spawns take down the pike, they stop spawning and Urok will NOT spawn.

https://youtu.be/2RqoKtMHavk?t=2692 https://youtu.be/L8a-9CYQk1g?t=4165

Steps to reproduce the problem

.go game 99791 .additem 12533 .additem 12534

Extra Notes

AC rev. hash/commit

https://github.com/chromiecraft/azerothcore-wotlk/commit/420ca2e2b57216b90f93e2deb870946b420a72df

Operating system

Ubuntu 20.04

Modules

Customizations

None

Server

ChromieCraft

patou01 commented 2 years ago

While riding my bike I had one more clarification needed on behaviour, to be sure everybody's on the same page. What should happen if the group wipes but Urok is spawned and some adds are still spawned?

Or should he only spawn after the last add dies? I'm pretty sure in the videos he spawns before all mobs are dead.

Shineslippers commented 2 years ago

There is question about should adds despawn or not. I don't think we can find Wrath videos on it. Classic Orok despawning and ads too. Since Wrath Urok should not despawn it leading to ads should not despawn too after Urok's Tribute Pile disapear. This is just my assumption.

UltraNix commented 2 years ago

What is the status of this? What problems remain?

Shineslippers commented 2 years ago

There is need dev to solve this @patou01 said he can't.

UltraNix commented 2 years ago

This - means?

Shineslippers commented 2 years ago

This issue/report:

The mobs should attack the pike if there is no players around
The boss should not despawning after appear
Urok's Tribute Pile with Pike and Head should disapear after Urok appear

UltraNix commented 2 years ago

Okay

patou01 commented 2 years ago

The part that I don't know how to do is mobs should attack the pike. If we have an example of an event where we do it, I can probably try to copy that.

The rest should be decently simple logic once the edge case of "the group wipes after Urok has spawned but there's still adds". Because that could lead to a bizarre scene in game. The vector containing all the needed mobs is already present UrokMobs

Edit: However, I don't think I can guarantee to be done before Friday if I take it. I should be able to do it before wednesday but unsure.

patou01 commented 2 years ago

Huh. He's set to despawn after 30s out of combat, at least that's what I ahd.

patou01 commented 2 years ago

@Ultranix, apparently I forgot to make him set the event to failed when he despawns, leading to it not being possible to restart the event.

UltraNix commented 2 years ago

The mobs don't attack the Pike with Head I need more info about that part. I see in the video that mobs start attacking that pile, but this is just a gameobject - it cannot be killed. I don't what is this

patou01 commented 2 years ago

If you can make them attack the pile and count the swings, then we can set a limit on the number of swings on the pike.

Else, maybe we can make them attack an invisible dummy? But that would probably be visible in the target of target.

UltraNix commented 2 years ago

I don't think so there is some dummy target.

patou01 commented 2 years ago

Maybe there's some other event like this where we can find inspiration, but I can't think of any.

edit: What about some of the quests where a player has to right click an egg to destroy it, how do we do these?

Shineslippers commented 2 years ago

To be clear. I'm already not sure about possibility or resummon like saying https://github.com/azerothcore/azerothcore-wotlk/issues/8712. There is no proofs to it. In the video where Pile was destroed players can't do it again, because no Pile. Found this comment also:

223389 on 2009/03/26 (Patch 3.0.9) The first wave, 3 ogres, one attacked the pike, I got a server message "Urok Enforcer attacks the pike!". I didn't know how this quest played out so I just killed all the ogres. It seems the pike is gone, there remains a circle of rocks. What am I suposed to do? Protect the pike? It seemed like they killed the pike very fast. Also, whe I initiated the event, there were several blue glowing spots on the floor, any idea what that was for? They went away when the event was over. But no summon :( Any help?

About the object issue. Violet Hold event. NPCs casting something to object.

UltraNix commented 2 years ago

Casting is possible, but gameobject is not a living object, so cannot be killed. I think this might be just an animation of hitting that pike.

patou01 commented 2 years ago

Yes, so we need to count the time that they're within that gameobject "hitting" it and not having another target. That should do the trick, then it's figuring out how long is allowed, and I guess they also shouldn't aggro anyone in range (ie they need to be attacked to engage combat)

UltraNix commented 2 years ago

Yes. On spawn should move towards to that pike and try to attack it. And your task is to aggro and protect.. But still need know that timer

azerothcore / azerothcore-wotlk