bSI-InfraRoom / IFC-Tunnel-Deployment

The IFC Tunnel Deployment documentation, examples and discussions
8 stars 32 forks source link

First attempt for Sprin2_1 #116

Closed JanErikHoel closed 1 year ago

JanErikHoel commented 1 year ago

File

Second try of sprint 2_2

Covered Concept Templates - Usages Included

Think I've covered all aspects

Miscellaneous

Please use this area to convey anything else.

JanErikHoel commented 1 year ago

I'm afraid I now need some help to find out why the ifcProject and/or ifcGroup fails and why the ifcAlignmentHorizontal fails

SergejMuhic commented 1 year ago

I'm afraid I now need some help to find out why the ifcProject and/or ifcGroup fails and why the ifcAlignmentHorizontal fails

Your #608 IfcGroup is not declared on IfcProject. It should be declared as in IfcRelDeclares on IfcProject. It should not be referenced in spatial structure. There is no concept template that would allow this. IfcRelReferencedInSpatialStructure had one partially documented usage that was never used consistently. It was to be used to reference IfcCurtainWall in IfcBuildingStorey if a facade stretched over one storey.

A quick glance tells me that your IfcAlignmenthorizontal does not have a CLOTHOID segment.

JanErikHoel commented 1 year ago

Hurrayyy!!!

JanErikHoel commented 1 year ago

Thanks for SUPER-QUICK and very useful help Sergej!!

pjanck commented 1 year ago

all uses of Project declaration were collected in one IfcRelDeclares

I'm unsure if that would be correct - see here.

larswik commented 1 year ago

all uses of Project declaration were collected in one IfcRelDeclares

I'm unsure if that would be correct - see here.

I see the point for nesting, but fail to see the point for declarations.

SergejMuhic commented 1 year ago

all uses of Project declaration were collected in one IfcRelDeclares

I'm unsure if that would be correct - see here.

Project Declaration is one usage though ... 😬

pjanck commented 1 year ago

As said, I was unsure and I stand corrected! Thank you for clearing it out for me! :)