search

badmojr / 1Hosts

World's most advanced DNS filter-/blocklists!
https://o0.pages.dev
Mozilla Public License 2.0
1.43k stars 82 forks source link

IHG Hotels (cdn(s).gigya.com) #1694

Open tomlbh opened 4 months ago

tomlbh commented 4 months ago


Submit Form

Get your issue resolved quickly! Fill in the form accurately.

Lists in use:

Client: Control D (controld.com) free DNS


Domains:

cdn.gigya.com
cdns.gigya.com


Details:

Without access to cdn.gigya.com (or possibly cdns.gigya.com) I cannot sign in to ihg.com

Thank you for supporting 1Hosts.

It’s people like you who make these lists great! ❤
spirillen commented 4 months ago

it seems "safe" to only blacklists

gscounters.au1.gigya.com
gscounters.eu1.gigya.com
gscounters.gigya.com
gscounters.us1.gigya.com
socialize.eu1.gigya.com

I'm not sure about, this list is the only one holding these. I blacklist the entire domain as it is nothing but tracking 

########################################################################
## Thanks to [My Privacy DNS](https://mypdns.org/) for this knowledge ##
########################################################################

####################################################################
#                                                                  #
# Found these RPZ records from My Privacy DNS                      #
#                                                                  #
# id    domain records  type    content
21285773        *.gigya.com.tracking.mypdns.cloud       type    .
21285772        gigya.com.tracking.mypdns.cloud type    . #
#                                                                  #
####################################################################
cdn2.gigya.com
cdn3.gigya.com
cdn.gigya.com
tomlbh commented 4 months ago

I agree that this domain is sketchy. It is however, blocked on all the 1hosts lists, dropping to a less strict list does not fix the breakage, perhaps it would meet the criteria to be removed from the lite list as it does hamper user experience? It is apparent from issues raised on other lists that cdn.gigya.com provides legitimate login functions: https://github.com/anudeepND/blacklist/issues/169

spirillen commented 4 months ago

That issue is very very old in this case as things are changed faster than I can breath.

However I can see in my search project that @UltimateHostsBlacklist also blocks cdn*.

data/ShadowWhispererTracking.txt:gscounters.eu1.gigya.com
data/ShadowWhispererTracking.txt:gscounters.us1.gigya.com
data/UltimateHostsBlacklist0.txt:cdn.gigya.com
data/UltimateHostsBlacklist1.txt:gscounters.eu1.gigya.com
data/UltimateHostsBlacklist1.txt:gscounters.gigya.com
data/UltimateHostsBlacklist1.txt:gscounters.us1.gigya.com
data/UltimateHostsBlacklist2.txt:socialize.eu1.gigya.com
data/adguardDNS.txt:gscounters.gigya.com
data/badmojr1Hosts.txt:gscounters.eu1.gigya.com
data/badmojr1Hosts.txt:gscounters.us1.gigya.com
data/badmojr1Hosts.txt:gscounters.au1.gigya.com
data/badmojr1Hosts.txt:cdn.gigya.com
data/badmojr1Hosts.txt:cdn2.gigya.com
data/badmojr1Hosts.txt:cdn3.gigya.com
data/badmojr1Hosts.txt:www.gigya.com
data/hphosts/ad_servers/domain.list:gscounters.eu1.gigya.com
data/hphosts/ad_servers/domain.list:gscounters.us1.gigya.com
data/migueldemouraAdsTracking.txt:gscounters.eu1.gigya.com