search

bambulab / BambuStudio

PC Software for BambuLab and other 3D printers
GNU Affero General Public License v3.0
2.2k stars 295 forks source link

Maximum layer height "too large layer height" #5356

Open johnnydoesdesign opened 1 day ago

johnnydoesdesign commented 1 day ago

Bambu Studio Version

1.10.1.50

Where is the application from?

Bambu Lab Official website

OS version

macOS 15.1

Additional system information

Apple MacStudio, M1 Ultra 20 core-CPU 48 core-GPU, 64GB RAM

Printer

Bambu LAb P1S

How to reproduce

  1. Load model
  2. in prepare > Quality set a layer height exceeding 0.6mm (eg. 0.64mm)
  3. Get an error message: "too large layer height. reset to 0.2mm"
  4. be annoyed ;)

Actual results

Theres a hard coded limit for layer heights at 0.6mm. This shouldnt be the case. Why would it be?

Expected results

No hardcoded layer height limit. Instead have an option in the printer settings, to limit layer height (max and min for that matter) to a resonable number depending on the installed nozzle size. 0.6mm doesnt make any sense as its too large for the standard 0.4mm nozzle but too little for a 0.8mm nozzle printing a 1.4mm wall thickness.

Project file & Debug log uploads

BambuStudio layer height issue.3mf.zip

Checklist of files to include

clstr commented 20 hours ago

I loaded up your 3mf on the same version and it slices fine.

johnnydoesdesign commented 20 hours ago

have you tried changing the layer height to anything larger than 0.6mm though?

clstr commented 19 hours ago

have you tried changing the layer height to anything larger than 0.6mm though?

Ah, apologies, I see the same error despite the extruder limits being set higher.

clstr commented 19 hours ago

This piece of code here seems relevent

https://github.com/bambulab/BambuStudio/blob/1540fbd9065d6b92246715ca40f4ec693c4807ea/src/libslic3r/Slicing.cpp#L42

Given a .8 nozzle and following the 3/4 guideline .75*.8 = .6

// Maximum layer height for the variable layer height algorithm, 3/4 of a nozzle dimaeter by default,
// it should not be smaller than the minimum layer height.
johnnydoesdesign commented 19 hours ago

Mhh in. my view it shouldnt be dependant on the nozzle diameter but the line width as you can print significantly wider lines with a nozzle than it's bore is in diameter. Iam printing 1.4mm lines with bambulabs 0.8mm nozzle without issues, so for that linewidth a layer height of 1,05mm should be acceptable.