Proof reading paper list

[cdcooper84]

The ')' in the bottom of the RHS of eq. 16 should be after dphi/dn

[ncclementi]

• [x] Wrong ')' in RHS of eq 16 The ')' in the bottom of the RHS of eq. 16 should be after dphi/dn

• [x] In the Figures that have (a) and (b) replace (top) and (bottom) to make reference to (a) and (b)

[ncclementi]

Check list

• [x] 1 Please specify base of logarithm or use natural log (ln).
• [x] 2 Please specify base of logarithm or use natural log (ln).
• [x] 3 Please note that there must be a citation of Figure 12 somewhere after the citation of Fig. 11 (your only citations of Fig. 12 occur earlier in the paper). Please check this inserted citation and relocate if necessary (but make sure it’s after the Fig. 11 citation).
• [x] 4 Please provide page number.
• [x] 5 Please check page number.
• [x] 6 Please provide city of publication for Refs. [28,30].
• [x] 7 Please check insertion of name and location of publisher.
• [x] 8 Please provide working URL.
• [x] 9 Please verify update volume number.
• [x] FQ: This funding provider could not be uniquely identified during our search of the FundRef registry (or no Contract or Grant number was detected). Please check information and amend if incomplete or incorrect.
• [x] Q: This reference could not be uniquely identified due to incomplete information or improper format. Please check all information and amend if applicable.

[ncclementi]

Talk to Lorena about:

• [x] Comment 3
• How PyGBe is written

[labarba]

For items 1 and 2, add in the response to the galley proof:

• The base of logarithm used is technically irrelevant, because the big-O in front indicates that we are talking about the scaling of the computational work with problem size N. The scaling is simply a slope in a log-log plot, with any base. Specifying the base of the logarithm in the text would make an incorrect narrative.

[labarba]

Reference DOIs missing:

[10] https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevB.72.155412 [35] https://doi.org/10.6084/m9.figshare.154331.v3 [41] https://doi.org/10.6084/m9.figshare.7504271.v1 [42] https://doi.org/10.6084/m9.figshare.7504307.v1 [44] https://doi.org/10.6084/m9.figshare.7504484.v1 [45] http://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.2511600 [46] http://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.2513715 [47] https://doi.org/10.6084/m9.figshare.7506167.v1

Note: the problem with missing links to references originates from pasting the .bbl file into the .tex after processing with the RevTeX style (which strips all DOIs from references!!).

Reference [26] -- Update URL to: https://github.com/pygbe/pygbe Reference [36] -- Update URL to: http://pygbe.github.io/pygbe/docs/