barbagroup / snake-repro

An article reporting the travails of reproducibility in unsteady CFD studies
https://lorenabarba.com/news/reproducible-and-replicable-cfd-its-harder-than-you-think/
26 stars 4 forks source link

Associate Editor comments #6

Open labarba opened 8 years ago

labarba commented 8 years ago

Editor Comments to the Author:

The reviewers have made a number of useful comments that I feel will overall improve the manuscript. In particular, I direct the authors attention to comments about the stability of the problem, and there are some specific suggestions that the reviewers make that could improve clarity of language. Otherwise, I too agree with the reviewers that this paper is very important, and I look forward to seeing its impact on the field.