search

bbc / bmx

Library and utilities to read and write broadcasting media files. Primarily supports the MXF file format
BSD 3-Clause "New" or "Revised" License
57 stars 16 forks source link

Reviving DNxHR support? #60

Open cmcfadden opened 4 months ago

cmcfadden commented 4 months ago

Howdy all - Just curious if there's been any ongoing discussion around DNxHR since Thomas Gritzan did his work a few years ago (thread, repo)? I'd love to make use of bmxtranswrap for generating DNxHR opatom files, and looked at pulling Thomas' branch into the current project - it seems mostly fine, though the files aren't working in Avid at the moment.

I couldn't find much more discussion about DNxHR though, so I'm curious if there's a philosophical reason it isn't covered in this project?

philipnbbc commented 4 months ago

There's no philosophical reason for not supporting it. It's not a format that I've needed in my work and so can't spend time resolving issues and completing submissions; it's up to the contributor to address the comments I had in that thread. It's also more complicated now that I don't have the same access to Avid editors, which makes it harder to validate files.