search

bbloomf / christmas-carols

A Collection of Christmas Carols
http://acollectionofchristmascarols.com
Other
34 stars 10 forks source link

"Es ist ein Ros entsprungen" alto notes #3

Closed maiamcc closed 7 years ago

maiamcc commented 7 years ago

Hi there!

I'm putting together a carol collection of my own and have been using some of your files as starting points---thank you for your work in putting this together, and making it available for others!

I noticed a note error in Es ist ein Ros entsprungen in the alto part at the very end. Your edition has the last two bars of the alto part:

  g4 e fis2( |
  d4) d d2 \bar "|."

when it should read:

  g4 e fis8( g |
  a d,4) d2 \bar "|."

See e.g. this video.

Also, every version of this piece I've ever sung has the text von Jes -- se kam __ die Art -- Wikipedia has the text you've provided (war die Art) but I can't find any other source.

Thanks for this great resource!

maiamcc commented 7 years ago

...hmm, found a few other note errors. I'm changing the engraving a bit for my version anyway, I can just make a pull request!

bbloomf commented 7 years ago

Fixed in latest commit. Thanks for letting me know about this.