bdlukaa / fluent_ui

Implements Microsoft's WinUI3 in Flutter.
https://bdlukaa.github.io/fluent_ui/
BSD 3-Clause "New" or "Revised" License
2.98k stars 465 forks source link

🐛 `NavigationAppBar`'s `automaticallyImplyLeading` behavior is wrong #1051

Open mateusfccp opened 7 months ago

mateusfccp commented 7 months ago

Describe the bug Currently, automaticallyImplyLeading just puts a back arrow or remove it. Even when there is no route below the current one (example, if you use it in a root page), an back arrow will appear.

To Reproduce Use an NavigationAppBar with automaticallyImplyLeading: true, which is the default. Note that the back arrow button will be the leading even if there's no route below.

Expected behavior The back arrow should appears if, and only if, there's a route below, which the behavior of popping the current route.

The same behavior as Flutter's Material AppBar. It even uses the same documentation.

bdlukaa commented 7 months ago

In some Windows apps, the arrow is displayed even when there is no route to pop. This behavior is usually true when the app consider the navigation view as a route history.

WinUI 3 Gallery WinUI 3 Gallery

On other apps, this behavior is not respected:

Microsoft Store Home Microsoft Store Games

Microsoft Store

We could, indeed, add an option to customize this behavior, but it is really hard to follow a pattern when there is not a pattern.

We follow the guidance provided in the NavigationView documentation:

Any major changes to NavigationView should be made after #919 is addressed.

mateusfccp commented 7 months ago

You are right, I just read the documentation and there are few instructions about the back button.

image image

Considering this documentation, I think automaticallyImplyLeading is a misleading name, specailly because it is the same name and uses the same documentation as the Material counterpart.

Instead, then, we should use the same name as in the documentation, that is, isBackButtonVisible.