benjaffe / chrome-okc-plugin

OkCupid Poly Plugin
MIT License
62 stars 32 forks source link

Scoring for "Is jealousy healthy in the context of a relationship?" is conflicting #108

Open AstraLuma opened 9 years ago

AstraLuma commented 9 years ago

For the question "Is jealousy healthy in the context of a relationship?" in the non-monogamy categories, I've seen red dots for both "Yes" and "No".

benjaffe commented 9 years ago

Hmm, can you confirm? The question, if we're talking about the same one, is

"Jealousy: healthy or unhealthy, in the context of a relationship?"

In relationship_model.js, it has the proper scores, so if this bug is happening, it'd potentially be a bug in the view code (which I haven't seen bugs in yet). LMK if you can reproduce.

stn4d89 commented 8 years ago

This one has been annoying me for ages!

At issue: Someone who agrees that "jealousy is unhealthy is a relationship" should gain points for "not possessive."

image

The issue MIGHT be because the wording of the question has changed, though it doesn't appear that the polarity changed.

Interjection: I just ran into: ![image](https://cloud.githubusercontent.com/assets/15327189/10753960/067602a0-7c5a-11e5-99a0-1705ba5a3d8c.png) and ![image](https://cloud.githubusercontent.com/assets/15327189/10754185/aa520cc4-7c5b-11e5-8b1e-6a193ea73ce0.png) The change in wording should probably be addressed, but I think there is something else going on (as well?).
526         "not_possessive": [
527             {
528                 "qid":"1440",
529                 "text":"Jealousy: healthy or unhealthy, in the context of a relationship?",
530                 "answerText": ["Healthy", "Unhealthy"],
531                 "score": [-1, 1],
532                 "weight": [0.5, 0.5]
533             },

Current suggestion output (score/weight changes mine): {"qid":"1440","text":" Is jealousy healthy in a relationship? ","answerText":["Yes","No"],"score":[-1,1],"weight":[0.5,0.5]}

Nonetheless, adding the above line might knock something loose.