Idea: Avoid symlinking the Makefiles

[mikegerber]

(Merely an idea/suggestion, not a wishlist thing. I just read ocrd-make the first time.) The way I use "the backend Makefile" is that I have this in my "frontend" eval.mk:

# Determine directory of this file – must be at the top before other includes
SELF_DIR := $(dir $(lastword $(MAKEFILE_LIST)))

# [...]

include $(SELF_DIR)Makefile

This is – I think – the most elegant way to find the Makefile from my eval.mk, assuming both are in the same directory. Then I can just use:

cd /path/to/some/directory/of/workspaces
make -f /usr/local/src/workflow-configuration/eval.mk

I have simplified a bit because I run this by container, but it should be correct like this.

[bertsky]

I remember make was severely restricted in search directory resolution. This was quite a struggle under various circumstances (esp. -C and recursive invocation), despite using -I and abspath.

This is worth another try though. If it does work, then not only does config symlinking/copying become unnecessary, but ocrd-make itself.

However, it's something of a stain to that new simpler UI that you have to remember (and type) the full path where workflow-configuration has been installed. That's were (a complete rewrite of) ocrd-make could step in: It could delegate to its install-time SHAREDIR, thus translating…

ocrd-make -j -f eval.mk all

…to your…

make -j -f /usr/local/src/workflow-configuration/eval.mk all

[bertsky]

Ok, so the situation is this: your idea of course works in that anyone can write their local workflow configurations like that (with the abspath include $(SELFDIR)/Makefile) and then call them from anywhere by make -f full/path/to/config.mk. But I don't want to rewrite existing configurations (both the old examples in the repo and all my local makefiles) for that little gain. The alternative (without modifying the configs) is to just use make -I full/path/to -f full/path/to/config.mk.

Unfortunately, there is no simple way to make a wrapper ocrd-make out of this pattern that would enable calling the makefile without its full path. The reason is that make -I SEARCHDIR -f CFGFILE does not use the searchdir to resolve the cfgfile path, and I don't want to start parsing the parameters externally and guessing which prefixes to add, and whether users have their files under the install location or elsewhere.

[bertsky]

@mikegerber, we can close this because in 1746daafc4e3a5ebdbc6d12db0db32d8e25388aa I decided against top-level (recursive) make anyway. The new ocrd-make does not symlink/copy makefiles (in fact, it adds a -I so there is no need for path name resolution of the main Makefile anymore).

See https://github.com/bertsky/workflow-configuration/issues/21 for the general idea (and further perspectives).