titheinfo highest ROI is showing negative number

[fogoat]

Perhaps it is due to PoG difficulty value being above 65536, but highest ROI (last metric) on titheinfo is showing as a negative number.

10:39:08 |   | titheinfo
10:39:08 |   | {   "24_hour_tithes": 128902.4,
   "pog_difficulty": 166639.1616298037,
   "min_coin_age": 60,
   "min_coin_amt": 25000,
   "max_tithe_amount": 1,
   "Tithable_Coin_Quantity": 0,
   "Tithable_Largest_Coin": 0,
   "Tithable_Coin_Avg_Age": 0,
   "Tithable_Total_Coin_Balance": 0,
   "Tithability_Amount": 0,
   "Tithability_Summary": "NO",
   "Tithe_Cap": 50694,
   "Daily_Miner_Emissions": 94628,
   "Pool_Emissions": 75702.40000000001,
   "Lowest_ROI%": 16.5,
   "Highest_ROI%": -35 }

[biblepay]

This is correct, at that particular time - since the pool inducted more than the extrapolated daily tithe cap over the last 40 blocks with legal tithes.. Im discussing some potential small tweaks with MIP now that I think will permanently solve that - maybe we can propose these in tandem with retiring PODC. One is decreasing the max tithe to 3 bbp or so. The other is requiring 1 day of coin age at diff 0. If we did these two things the ROI should always be stable and run ups over short-term block counts wont cause the ROI to change much.

[fogoat]

Okay, thanks for the explanation.

You can PoG Tithe from the GUI multiple times before PoG difficulty changes which I think is causing the daily cap to be exceeded.

One is decreasing the max tithe to 3 bbp or so.

We are going from 300 BBP to 3 BBP? Does that seem aggressive?

[biblepay]

I think 3 bbp would mean lower avg diff and more frequent tithes, but would allow up to 20,000 concurrent new users in the pool per day. 30 would work also, but I dont think 3 hurts anyone (it just increases tithe frequency).

[fogoat]

When I type titheinfo, I'm seeing Lowest_ROI% as -184.5