apemithrandir
commented
1 year ago @jmacxx thanks very much for putting together that estimate. What does the procedure for getting DAO approval look like? Is this a task that would interest you to implement? If we get DAO approval I will pledge 1m Sats for part 1 and an additional 3m Sats for part 2, with a 1 year deadline attached to my bounty from the date of DAO approval.
@jmacxx great work getting part 1 implemented in v1.9.11. I will contact you for the 1m sat bounty
pazza83
I am back again. There has been increased discussion on the Growth channel about this feature and I would like to propose it again. Here is my previous proposal: https://github.com/bisq-network/proposals/issues/370 Here is @wiz's original proposal: https://github.com/bisq-network/proposals/issues/201 Here is @pazza83's related proposal: https://github.com/bisq-network/proposals/issues/288
Background
Short Version If I am a maker on Bisq the biggest restriction to me posting multiple offers is the escrow requirement for each offer. Supposing I have access to 3 different currencies and 2 different payment methods for each currency. then if I wanted to create a buy offer for each of these I would have to escrow a minimum of 15% deposit + fees for each of the 6 offers. If I am a seller this is even more restrictive as I will have to escrow a minimum of 115% deposit + fees for each of the 6 offers.
I would like to re-propose @pazza83's solution to this problem whereby you would create a special multi-payment account offer. See the other proposals for more background and discussion.
Description
@pazza83's proposal has the bulk of the details so I would refer people to: https://github.com/bisq-network/proposals/issues/288 I will make a few points of clarity in addition:
Technical
@chimp1984 was graceful enough to provide @pazza83's proposal with some useful technical feedback: https://github.com/bisq-network/proposals/issues/288#issuecomment-748426475
Neither myself or @pazza83 are qualified to implement this proposal, and this proposal will require more feedback from technically minded individuals.
Why Propose this Again?
I am proposing this again because most of the community agrees this would be an excellent feature to implement in Bisq in order to help bootstrap liquidity in smaller markets.
@wiz proposed this (or similar) idea over 1000 days ago, it was closed as approved but no project started. @pazza83 built on @wiz's proposal over 750 days ago, but this proposal was closed as stalled suggesting that Bisq 2.0 (or Misq as it was referred to then) might offer this improvement. Now we are close to getting a first beta version of Bisq 2.0 but this feature will not be available yet. It may be another 2 years until such features exist in Bisq 2.0, given our current developer resources.
I propose this for Bisq 1.0 again (rather than wait for Bisq 2.0) so that it can get approved and have a Development Budget allocation (as per here and here). If nobody within Bisq is willing to dedicate the time to this feature then I would like feedback from experienced contributors on how much work in Dev Days they might estimate this to take, possibly including the requirement of a new Dev to learn the codebase.
The community can then create a type of Job advertisement with the approximate DAO budget allocation plus our bounty Sats, together with details on approximate amount of work required. The community would go to market to advertise this and try and find a qualified developer(s) to join and take up the issue.
Even if this feature doesn't get implemented, I think having the budget allocation and bounty together with an advertisement will be useful to get eyes on Bisq and let qualified people know that there are paying jobs to be had working with the Bisq DAO.