This is a commercial challenge, not a technical one.
The Internet has never turned on Multicast for interdomain traffic, because there was never a viable business case for it. Many times it has been requested over the past 30 years. But the case was never convincing. Until, perhaps, now.
So how will they need convincing this time:
1) is the biz case big enough ?
2) will Bitcoin actually get adopted at scale?
3) a new IETF RFC standard or update looks necessary for multicast protocol adaptations. Who will pay for this?
Perhaps by starting out unicast transit as it is today because the host and network load is still relatively low, and ramping up over time will create the demand to activate the resources needed to do the convincing.
Isn't this leaving things rather up in the air though? And to leave this question virtually unattended while forging ahead with Teranode in a vacuum, risks having to roll back a hell of a lot of costly hard work at a later stage, due to unintended consequences.
BRC ID
BRC 80
Discussion
This is a commercial challenge, not a technical one.
The Internet has never turned on Multicast for interdomain traffic, because there was never a viable business case for it. Many times it has been requested over the past 30 years. But the case was never convincing. Until, perhaps, now.
So how will they need convincing this time:
1) is the biz case big enough ? 2) will Bitcoin actually get adopted at scale? 3) a new IETF RFC standard or update looks necessary for multicast protocol adaptations. Who will pay for this?
Perhaps by starting out unicast transit as it is today because the host and network load is still relatively low, and ramping up over time will create the demand to activate the resources needed to do the convincing.
Isn't this leaving things rather up in the air though? And to leave this question virtually unattended while forging ahead with Teranode in a vacuum, risks having to roll back a hell of a lot of costly hard work at a later stage, due to unintended consequences.
See here for more detail: https://bit.ly/3KjdiV7