search

bitfocus / companion-module-behringer-x32

Behringer x32 module for companion
MIT License
20 stars 7 forks source link

Change from mute state feedback not working when multiple inputs being muted simultaneously #92

Open JaaHann opened 1 year ago

JaaHann commented 1 year ago

When toggling mute on multiple inputs at the same time (via Companion and directly via the x32), the corresponding feedback is not changing in Companion. Only after changing the mute state on a single input, all feedbacks then update to the right state.

I'm using v3.0.0+5939 beta

lukasztabo commented 1 year ago

Exactly the same issue! Let me know in case you were able to figure this out eventually?

discodancepant commented 1 year ago

@JaaHann @lukasztabo

I'm using three streamdecks, I have the same page pulled up across all of them. I can hit multiple buttons on any of them at the same time and have no issues with actual muting on the X32 or the feedback of the buttons. The only time I see an issue is when the SAME button is pressed at the same time on multiple panels. IE one person goes to turn on channel one at the exact same time as person B turn on channel one. they effectively turned on and off the channel instantly.

For this very reason, I make sure my streamdecks do NOT have access to the same pages (and buttons) at the same time.

What is your X32 firmware rev. and companion firmware rev.?

rjstudiosaustralia commented 5 months ago

I have had the same issue too. Seem to be able to have recreated it.

I setup 2 buttons, one did a single mute of channel 1 with a feedback instance on that same channel, on pressing it it follows the feedback The second button is toggling mute of channels 1 and 2 and getting feedback of just 1 and is not following when the button is pressed. If I press mute on x32 control software the feedback works, it just doesnt seem to be getting feedback when pressed on companion doing multiple things at once. There is nothing in the log when pressed.. Please help! I really want to go to version 3 but this is making it unusable for me sadly :( Thanks for all you do! Companion v3.2.2 Stable x32 v4.08

leonreucher commented 1 month ago

Same problem for me - multiple mute actions in the same button leads to no feedback from the console inside of companion. Probably as a temporary solution add an action to sync the status, and add this as the last action?