bitpool / edge-bacnet

A bitpool-edge bacnet gateway for Node-RED
MIT License
11 stars 7 forks source link

cannot write some value #11

Closed websystemsoftware closed 7 months ago

websystemsoftware commented 10 months ago

the Product is very nice.. but it have some bugs i think.. i can read data without problems but it is not possible to write any Data!

and also some crazy stuff happend when i go with the standard settings from time to time the Devices goes offline and come online, the complete devices are gone and so on... after a time it was showing me 0 Devices, all devices are gone and come not back... after i uninstall and install the edge-bacnet new in nodered it found all the devices again...

i think the problem comes when i test to write someting, and writing is not working.... when i was looking with yabe the devices was always perfectly online with no problems only edge-bacnet have this problem was lost always the connection of devices...

i change now in the Gateway Node some settings in Device Discover Frequency and Object Discover Frequency to a higher value and now look better > it lost no connections anymore at the moment....

but the biggest problem is it is not possible to write some Values!!

gives here a solution to bring write a value working, or comes a update for this problen in the next time?

Thanks for your nice work

Benny

websystemsoftware commented 10 months ago

bacnet-write

the debug shows this after write... but it writes not correctly the presentValue to the device... when i change the value in yabe tool then it is working and i can change the presentValue from the yabe tool without problems

but when i write with edge-bacnet node nothing is write to the presentValue

here i was sending a Number 4 with the inject node but nothing changes in the device presentValue

davidjnblanch commented 10 months ago

We are aware of the write issue along with other big fix’s and have a new release out soon, can you please provide details on the system and setup , is this bacnet mstp or ip ? Also export flow json and send to so we can see config..

Also your host device nodered is running on what is the operating system and is this running as a docker container

cheers

websystemsoftware commented 10 months ago

yabe

Hello we use NodeRed 3.1.0 and your plugin in Version 1.2.6 we use Bacnet IP i send you also a printscreen out of yabe tool of our system

dblanchie commented 10 months ago

Hello

we use NodeRed 3.1.0 and your plugin in Version 1.2.6

we use Bacnet IP

i send you also a printscreen out of yabe tool of our system

No worries, is your node device running on windows or Linux, is the bacnet device bacnet ip or mstp ?

websystemsoftware commented 10 months ago

we runing NodeRed on a Linux System and the bacnet device is IP

dblanchie commented 10 months ago

we runing NodeRed on a Linux System

and the bacnet device is IP

Thanks can you provide device manufacturer and model, we will send you an update when the new release is available. We will also have ui improvements and bug fixes

websystemsoftware commented 10 months ago

writetothispoint

and this is our WriteList where i want to write the value > change the Present Value

ok i will check the device manufactur quick the device > Bacnet IP Gateway was installing by a heating company...

dblanchie commented 10 months ago

writetothispoint

and this is our WriteList where i want to write the value > change the Present Value

ok i will check the device manufactur quick

the device > Bacnet IP Gateway was installing by a heating company...

I can't make out from the original picture but it looks like a Siemens MSTP router making this device an mstp device that you are writing to, maybe wrong hence why I asked for the model but it looks that way from the yabe image. We have a known issue with mstp writing, we have tested bacnet ip writing and have had any issues to date. If you can get the make and model that would be great, I will message back here when the new update will be released, shouldn't be too long

websystemsoftware commented 10 months ago

LonBacnetRouter

helps you this printscreen with the Data? i think is a Siemens PXG Router LON/Bacnet

but how i say this device installtion makes the heating company and iam only the IT Guy but when you need some more Infos about the device i must ask the heating company

Thanks Benny

dblanchie commented 10 months ago

LonBacnetRouter

helps you this printscreen with the Data?

i think is a Siemens PXG Router LON/Bacnet

but how i say this device installtion makes the heating company and iam only the IT Guy

but when you need some more Infos about the device i must ask the heating company

Thanks

Benny

Thanks man yep the device you are writing to is mstp which means it's a 2 wire rs485 device that sits under the Siemens ip gateway...this is a known issue for us so all good fix will be available soon

websystemsoftware commented 10 months ago

thank you so much for your quick response and all of your work for this fantastic product!!!

i will wait for the Update

Greetings Benny

bitpool-dev commented 7 months ago

Received confirmation that writing to points is now functional.

Closing this issue.