On-chain trollbox - Githubissues

bitshares / bitshares-ui

Fully featured Graphical User Interface / Reference Wallet for the BitShares Blockchain

https://wallet.bitshares.org

MIT License

518 stars 570 forks source link

On-chain trollbox #2061

Open sschiessl-bcp opened 5 years ago

sschiessl-bcp commented 5 years ago

We had a trollbox in the UI a while back, and I just want to persist discussion on it future reference. Externally included trollbox was discarded due to spam and maintenance effort #281

On-chain trollbox that uses transfers to a predefined account whose private memo key is hardcoded in the UI. I remember we had a discussion on it somewhere, but couldnt find it. This issue is to collect opinions and have the discussion future-proof.

Benefits:

No outside plugin or dependency necessary
Shows capabilities of the chain
Collects network from active chatters (must be displayed to the user prominently of course)
Easy to implement
Cost might prevent Spam

Downside:

Delay of couple seconds in the chatting
Cost per message
Might not get adopted due to cost per message

Thoughts?

startailcoon commented 5 years ago

I believe you're thinking on https://github.com/bitshares/bitshares-ui/issues/697. I still think this would be a good idea, and a feature that could be a proof-of-concept for bitshares.

Yes, we will have a fee for chat, could be a negative aspect, but can't say it would a limitation.

sschiessl-bcp commented 5 years ago

Ah, yes that is the issue thank you!

Let's leave this open for when we get bored :)

fractalnode commented 5 years ago

in my opinion it is a waste of time at this stage and there are many more important things to do eg. enable Prediction Market for all, BSIP0019 and BSIP0020

sschiessl-bcp commented 5 years ago

BSIP0019 and BSIP0020

Both are not voted in.

1065

Agreed

fractalnode commented 5 years ago

BSIP0019 and BSIP0020 Both are not voted in.

they were deferred due to the confusion with bittrex and concerns about the recognition of BTS as security. I hope that the topic will come back and it will be implemented as soon as possible. In this way, we can take part of the ETH and EOS market.

startailcoon commented 5 years ago

Let's leave this open for when we get bored :)

Agreed. This issue is extremely low priority on our agenda. Suitable as a first time issue of concept by a new react developer (Summer of Code)