search

bitshares / bsips

BitShares Improvement Proposals and Protocols. These technical documents describe the process of updating and improving the BitShares blockchain and technical ecosystem.
https://bitshares.github.io
63 stars 86 forks source link

BSIP 86: Share market fees to the network #253

Closed abitmore closed 4 years ago

abitmore commented 4 years ago

PR for #194.

MichelSantos commented 4 years ago

The discussion is very good

My personal suggestion, which should be considered completely optional, is to consider adding a discussion point that says that the committee will be accumulating tokens which could potentially be used or not used for any purpose. In other words, this BSIP as currently written does not stipulate how those tokens will or will not be used by the committee.

MichelSantos commented 4 years ago

I conclude that the proposal is technically complete

sschiessl-bcp commented 4 years ago

@abitmore your review completed?

abitmore commented 4 years ago

@sschiessl-bcp: yes, I think so.

sschiessl-bcp commented 4 years ago

Status set to accepted. Merge at your own convenience

shulthz commented 4 years ago

I suggest to pause this BSIP until solved the legal risk.

This BSIP must make a statement for this kind lawsuit，how to deal? who will be responsible for these lawsuit? This BSIP must make a statement for this kind lawsuit to BTS holders.

This BSIP86 has legal risk, i suggest everyone need to consider it very carefully and seek a legal consultancy.

When BSIP86 charges the market fees from the GATEWAY.assets, the BTS system will have joint liability and must be responsible for these GATEWAY.assets, but these GATEWAY.assets were without supervision and control by the BTS system.

Gateway just likes the DApp of BTS, BTS just provides the service and takes the transaction fee of blockchain，DApp do what is not the business of BTS, but when BTS charges the market fees of GATEWAY.assets, the nature of things will become different.

sschiessl-bcp commented 4 years ago

I suggest to pause this BSIP until solved the legal risk.

This BSIP must make a statement for this kind lawsuit，how to deal? who will be responsible for these lawsuit? This BSIP must make a statement for this kind lawsuit to BTS holders.

This BSIP86 has legal risk, i suggest everyone need to consider it very carefully and seek a legal consultancy.

When BSIP86 charges the market fees from the GATEWAY.assets, the BTS system will have joint liability and must be responsible for these GATEWAY.assets, but these GATEWAY.assets were without supervision and control by the BTS system.

Gateway just likes the DApp of BTS, BTS just provides the service and takes the transaction fee of blockchain，DApp do what is not the business of BTS, but when BTS charges the market fees of GATEWAY.assets, the nature of things will become different.

The BSIP creates the technical framework. Without any active action, nothing will be activated. That will need to be done by committee setting the fee. Please direct your efforts towards committee members and make them aware.

shulthz commented 4 years ago

The BSIP creates the technical framework. Without any active action, nothing will be activated. That will need to be done by committee setting the fee. Please direct your efforts towards committee members and make them aware.

Yes, it is a technical framework, but it didn't indicate it has legal risk clearly in the MD, it makes a trap to bts holders and committee.

Committees have staff changes, at last, the bts holders will face the lawsuit.

Even it is a technical framework, but it must make a statement for so clearly legal risk to bts holders, let the bts holders clearly know what they will face in the future.