search

bitshares / bsips

BitShares Improvement Proposals and Protocols. These technical documents describe the process of updating and improving the BitShares blockchain and technical ecosystem.
https://bitshares.github.io
63 stars 86 forks source link

Create bsip-0087.md #265

Closed bitcrab closed 4 years ago

bitcrab commented 4 years ago

create a new PR for BSIP87 to replace the old messy one.

abitmore commented 4 years ago

Thanks.

bitcrab commented 4 years ago

modified the changed file according to your suggestion, please check again. @sschiessl-bcp @abitmore

sschiessl-bcp commented 4 years ago

@abitmore please advise, I feel the important thing is to keep it compatible to core code and BSIP74, which is already voted up.

1.14.239 | Poll - BSIP74 - Market Fee Ratiobitcrab currently has 464,918,785 votes, and to become active 715,885,028 are needed.

In order to establish 1.14.158 | threshold-bsip as the threshold for BSIPs it would need to either be mentioned in the BSIP-74 specifically, or the better option a BSIP needs to be written establishing a set of rules for when BSIPs become active that include 1.14.158 as the threshold. This new BSIP must then be passed with the old rules (become active by receiving part of the daily pay).

If you do not agree with me there, please elaborate why.

bitcrab commented 4 years ago

@abitmore please advise, I feel the important thing is to keep it compatible to core code and BSIP74, which is already voted up.

1.14.239 | Poll - BSIP74 - Market Fee Ratiobitcrab currently has 464,918,785 votes, and to become active 715,885,028 are needed.

In order to establish 1.14.158 | threshold-bsip as the threshold for BSIPs it would need to either be mentioned in the BSIP-74 specifically, or the better option a BSIP needs to be written establishing a set of rules for when BSIPs become active that include 1.14.158 as the threshold. This new BSIP must then be passed with the old rules (become active by receiving part of the daily pay).

If you do not agree with me there, please elaborate why.

the poll BSIP worker voting is just to ensure that the community agree to implement it, without considering budget.

1.14.158 is effective for all the BSIPs.

after that, one more voting for budget is needed, one BSIP can be included in a big budget worker or as a separate budget worker to accept approval, either is OK, IIRC we have experienced both.

I hope at this moment we can firstly focus on making the BSIP document ready and then discuss how to vote.

Chinese can build one hospital in 10 days, I don't think it's good to cost more than 10 days to prepare one document.

sschiessl-bcp commented 4 years ago

Chinese can build one hospital in 10 days, I don't think it's good to cost more than 10 days to prepare one document.

That comparison does not hold since the BitShares Blockchain does not have centralized decision making and/or "unlimited" funds.

the poll BSIP worker voting is just to ensure that the community agree to implement it, without considering budget.

1.14.158 is effective for all the BSIPs.

I understand the intent. 1.14.158 has not been approved as the new BSIP threshold by BTS holders, not for BSIP-74 (since it is not mentioned in there) nor for all BSIPs. It has only been created by committee. Should that be considered enough? And if so, why?

I have opened a new issue for this: #267. Let's stay on topic in this one.