bitwarden / clients

Bitwarden client apps (web, browser extension, desktop, and cli).
https://bitwarden.com
Other
8.98k stars 1.18k forks source link

Introduction of ”initials” avatar/profile images also introduced design/usability flaws … #2590

Open fooness opened 2 years ago

fooness commented 2 years ago

Steps To Reproduce

  1. install Bitwarden desktop
  2. open Bitwarden desktop

Expected Result

Two solutions to the described problem—see Additional Context—that I can currently think of would be:

  1. let the users define custom background colors and initials, and/or give an option to NOT use initials at all, i.e. just a colored background

  2. let the users upload their own avatar/profile images

Actual Result

Hard to distinguish avatar/profile images for different accounts.

Screenshots or Videos

Screen Shot 2022-02-11 at 16 33 43

Additional Context

The latest update to Bitwarden desktop, introducing the account switcher and with this the depiction of ”initials” avatar/profile images, i.e. the randomly background-colores two-letter avatar/profile images like e.g. BI, also introduces design/usability flaws; for example, two accounts could have the same initials and the same or at least hard to distinguish—also think about color vision impaired people—background colors.

The same basically also applies to Bitwarden web; also there an option to change the “initial” avatar/profile image is lacking.

Operating System

macOS

Operating System Version

12.2

Installation method

Other

Build Version

Version 1.31.0 (2262)

Hinton commented 2 years ago

Hi @fooness,

Thanks for reporting this. We are currently exploring alternative approaches to generating the avatars but as you mentioned randomized colors requires a bit of care to ensure they have good contrasts.

I've attached this issue to our internal issue as additional context.

dnicolson commented 2 years ago

The avatars also appear to be inconsistent across platforms. On web and iOS I see the first letter of the first and last names but on macOS the avatar is the first two letters of the first name.

Flat commented 2 years ago

Customization or the ability to completely disable this across clients would be nice. It's fairly useless for single account users.