bitwarden / mobile

Retired Bitwarden mobile app for iOS and Android (MAUI/Xamarin).
https://bitwarden.com
GNU General Public License v3.0
150 stars 24 forks source link

Bitwarden incorrectly shows its accessibility service as disabled #1058

Open Cp4QgQbCadDXBo1z2sM9IrXTO3zC3Wsec4gIcKQ opened 4 years ago

Cp4QgQbCadDXBo1z2sM9IrXTO3zC3Wsec4gIcKQ commented 4 years ago

Describe the Bug

When you press the "Auto-fill" tile in quick settings, you get an error message telling you to enable the accessibility service first. Despite this, autofill still shows up after tapping on a login/password field in most apps, but it doesn't work in browsers like Bromite, Samsung Internet, Mi Browser

Steps To Reproduce

  1. Set Bitwarden as your default autofill service
  2. Enable Bitwarden as an accessibility service
  3. Open a login page
  4. Add the Bitwarden Autofill tile to your quick settings and tap on it

Expected Result

The "Autofill with Bitwarden" screen should appear and you should be able to autofill your login credentials

Actual Result

After enabling the Bitwarden accessibility service, the app still shows that it's disabled. When you click on the autofill tile, it shows an error message telling you to enable the accessibility service first.

Environment

Additional Context

I tried switching my system language from Polish to English and it fixed the issue only the first time I opened the app (autofill in Bromite worked as well). After opening the app again it still doesn't acknowledge its service being enabled.

qWOKOXrMJYnA7HkbVr9e3MwvqyQWzaf0flygNju commented 4 years ago

+1 for this

W0OTSLHRpjuhn1QBF1FRUHMvnOI1ZKVzXr5NOQi commented 3 years ago

Having same problem on Redmi Note 9 Pro MIUI12 Android 10.

YkwdjeVJKaBpLbkubkQ7TRC4DHLRHyekaPv9YHU commented 3 years ago

Same issue on a Huawei P20 with EMIU 10.0 (Android 10) and Bitwarden v2.7.2 (3300)

1FCoCTOBQOi9dyCs7em7AIdTRbRCbKN49KvF4uI commented 3 years ago

i am having same issue with MIUI 12, in earlier MIUI version it worked as expected.

WwzWPkiyo5yjy6BufMGyPF1opOPOvjhGOUOD98w commented 3 years ago

Same as here, poco x3, MIUI 12.0.6 Android 10. But mine is a little different, it's work with browsers but not in bank apps fill. I tried turn off MIUI optimization, lock app, select auto start but it's work only one time, and then stop working.

FreQm5PEGcsNpc4SfKHTqhrCSn4Yox5i6dpCMNR commented 3 years ago

I have this issue on my Mi 11 Lite 5G using MIUI 12

GimxbLp6vfeMlu2KUuEImaDcZ4qfk6E48au76Px commented 3 years ago

Same issue on MI 9 using MIUI 12.0.5 Android 10.

s36FPgCzsDKJUc143pR3MEMl9JinMwi1VikRz6L commented 3 years ago

Same issue on LG LM-G850EMW, Android 10

g2xSlLk2gcadwvyB4gxYcWVMa7onctFyVQg4VDT commented 3 years ago

Same issue on Blackview BV5900 Android 9

Cp4QgQbCadDXBo1z2sM9IrXTO3zC3Wsec4gIcKQ commented 3 years ago

I want to confirm it's still an issue on MIUI 12 (Android 11), ver. 2.11.3

tsI0hdlmSkMj1ZdbY5set52G6isLRxvqokP10kT commented 3 years ago

Same issue on MIUI 12.0.15 with Android 10QP1A.190711.020 with 2021-06-01 security patch level.

Ygi6JszMsYO1VZXuOYwK25tVPY1gYjIsKC1fhA3 commented 3 years ago

Same issue in Mi 10T with MIUI 12.5.1

k7uyhJo1dOHiflZ8e3NWUPapn0ZydrnUzpYscDv commented 3 years ago

I'm having the same problem on my Samsung Galaxy S10e with Android 11

mpbw2 commented 3 years ago

Can everyone here see if this is still an issue in the current beta (build 3946)?

FreQm5PEGcsNpc4SfKHTqhrCSn4Yox5i6dpCMNR commented 3 years ago

@mportune-bw Forgive me but where can we download this? Is there an APK file somewhere, or a link where I can join the BETA program?

mpbw2 commented 3 years ago

@f3bruary You can join the beta on the Bitwarden page in the Play Store app (you should see a link to join somewhere on the page, and you can leave the beta at any time).

FreQm5PEGcsNpc4SfKHTqhrCSn4Yox5i6dpCMNR commented 3 years ago

I tested the beta. Same result. If I enable the a11y feature and go back it says (translated from Dutch)

Service not working properly. Click for more info.

Upon clicking: service is not working properly.

Also, when I force close the app and open it again the a11y option is disabled again.

So pretty much same as before.

My current issues are:

tsI0hdlmSkMj1ZdbY5set52G6isLRxvqokP10kT commented 3 years ago

I downloaded the beta version of the app and the issue was resolved

MIUI 12.0.16

g2xSlLk2gcadwvyB4gxYcWVMa7onctFyVQg4VDT commented 2 years ago

Same issue on Blackview BV5900 running Android 9

Like everyone here, the app is enabled in Accessibility, I have also loaded the app beforehand and the title is not greyed out like it can be sometimes but when you press it it gives the error message in screenshot. Screenshot_20211216-094357

g2xSlLk2gcadwvyB4gxYcWVMa7onctFyVQg4VDT commented 2 years ago

I downloaded the beta version of the app and the issue was resolved

MIUI 12.0.16

I am also running the beta version of Bitwarden but the problem persists for me.

WwzWPkiyo5yjy6BufMGyPF1opOPOvjhGOUOD98w commented 2 years ago

I'm using Poco X3 NFC android 11, MIUI 12.5.

I had noticed that if you allow it to autostart bitwarden it's working as expected. IMG_20220420_103928

q04mMRpJvxOZLam7S6nSLSKVxUvcynwbhG3AlfS commented 2 years ago

+1 same issue here on the Xiaomi Mi Pad 5 Pro

dY03Dv41HXHJZS0l2LjQRmnGnG7lTx6AINiEg3J commented 2 years ago

I too have this issue on a Galaxy A50. In apps (like the intermittent re-authentication in eBay) that have multiple stages for logging in (username, next panel, password) this causes an issue, where BitWarden will show the popover on the username field and input it, but on the next panel with the password it won't show the popover and using the tile will cause the error message to pop up. No way to login except switching to BitWarden, unlocking, searching, opening, copying the password, switching back and pasting the password.

kyAUOeIb9HL0y1O7bxn7MEQIb8tTjtcQF1Ydy4S commented 1 year ago

Tab A, Android 12... still an issue. Works for a couple of days, then accessibility is disabled. Very annoying.

vJEE82072ITebpoXV0ayhTmjBPTqVKeLsfjrYoa commented 1 year ago

+1

ntGDTOWzMLnAqEWQe27CaKkvwyElqP4hfQcpcr6 commented 1 year ago

Believe the same issue here. Pixel 7 Pro Android 14 + Nov '23 service pack.