bitwarden / mobile

Retired Bitwarden mobile app for iOS and Android (MAUI/Xamarin).
https://bitwarden.com
GNU General Public License v3.0
149 stars 24 forks source link

Copy & paste of password does not work (iphone->macbook) #1824

Open 0uEr28bYoHfcyos3CWSfyh5f2B0w2jfoBhaJBrE opened 2 years ago

0uEr28bYoHfcyos3CWSfyh5f2B0w2jfoBhaJBrE commented 2 years ago

Steps To Reproduce

  1. Have iPhone + MacBook copy & paste function setup
  2. Go to Bitwarden mobile app
  3. Click Login button
  4. Click 3 dots for one of the logins
  5. Click on Copy password button

Expected Result

I have acees to my copied password on MacBook.

Actual Result

I do not have access to my copied password.

Screenshots or Videos

No response

Additional Context

I am sure that my copy&paste feature works because pasting the password to notes app and then copying it again gives me access to it on my MacBook.

Additionally this feature was working. Seems like it broke in the last 2-3 weeks or so?

Operating System

iOS

Operating System Version

15.3.1

Device

iPhone XS

Build Version

Version: 2.16.2 (1434)

Beta

2CYKIZMj2pGo2WhwWo3chb1mduyovYHm7BuSWxX commented 2 years ago

Zero comments? This is maddening for a password manager to have non functional C/P.

hnt8pME3Td2d7Eo6fJlTBIte4tNwx1LCKm1btQQ commented 2 years ago

Yeah, I have the same issue. iPhone 11 Pro Max with iOS 15.5

2jkxfSqEOlxlJhMHQnwnN3PgUan1MrEg14borXZ commented 2 years ago

Looks like this was changed in December 21, the localOnly flag was set to true for pasteboard operations.

Seems like a setting that should be user configurable.

On one hand, a few people won't want their passwords being handed off to other devices when copied. However I think most people want to use their phone as a password vault(since iOS has a much stronger security posture than macOS), and copy passwords to their macOS device when they need to log in to something.

@fedemkr Thoughts on this?

fedemkr commented 2 years ago

Hi thank you all for the report and feedback. Yes, that was changed at the time taking into consideration security but it's been discussed and we're going to add a Setting that you can turn on to copy to other devices through Handoff feature (it will be disabled by default)

5TnZLRBwj0t3HadvCT5keTa8MTWeJ5QRfAozEWE commented 2 years ago

Hello, @fedemkr!

I'd like to try to solve this issue. Is it possible?

Thank you so much!

fedemkr commented 2 years ago

Hi @ionixjunior thanks so much but for now the team is researching some further considerations about this

N8SgBiv9tjedstHBoiF1TBsZNwmGacBlZsj4qkr commented 2 years ago

In the meantime, I've found a workaround to allow pasting passwords with continuity. Using the Shortcuts app, create a shortcut that takes your current clipboard and copies it again to the clipboard, add it to your Home Screen, and after copying the desired password on the Bitwarden app, tap on the shortcut.

UHOvIzri9R7z9aMNVCkfUqdgbl2KNvRihiIQlfv commented 1 year ago

any news on this? it's really annoying having to use workarounds to make such a basic thing to work.

5qNaPEpmOv8Q1dDgQrvruXnI6K2ARY0aSCcUepR commented 1 year ago

This feature was disabled in the name of security, but to work-around it I usually paste the password into another app and then copy it again which is less secure than if this just worked.

Qxv1AubXuQObs9HY1Vx6tMZ4pB2OsPpIyKL0341 commented 1 year ago

As other users have suggested, this just creates an open security hole since I've been copy / pasting between apps and then between devices for this to work. Since in my work laptop I cannot have bitwarden installed I cannot rely on extensions or the bitwarden app.

SPIueXDze9n4hVUlSRqmgKjjetBK1cLttGq5t4j commented 1 year ago

IMO having the Desktop App on your computer is LESS secure. I'm only using Bitwarden on iOS, and I copy/paste SINGLE passwords over handoff.

I've seen someones Macbook being compromised recently. It would be really trivial for a malware to copy the entire Bitwarden App with settings + vault. Then it just has to wait listening for you to type your master password the first time you have to log in into any insert random website. Boom! Now your ENTIRE life is gone.

I much rather have less security for SINGLE passwords, than having my master password being constantly exposed to malwares, I type that like hundreds of times in a day.

Just make this a setting please.

kczssGvaUchPTpAdSdtyUvU4ZLgVCuT5pVSt16Y commented 1 year ago

@fedemkr any update on this? I'm currently trying to move away from an old OTP application which is no longer supported on iOS and move to using Bitwarden (I figure I'm paying for BW, I might as well use all the features) but the fact that I can't copy/paste OTP codes from my phone to my browser/etc is becoming a real pain ... so much so that I'm considering changing password managers to something which does support this.

I note that a year ago you said a unilateral change was made and it looked like there was going to be a user configurable option to enable/disable localOnly on pasteboard actions ... this would, I think, solve my (and other people's) problems ..

My old OTP app allowed Universal Clipboard processing, and it made my life considerably easier (I have to OTP probably 50-60 times a day on different platforms) ... which is why this is so important to me.

wrrdJOLk92Ccam2LJrhZnDMU82ZXNWN1oIPu9YO commented 1 year ago

Hi @fedemkr,

On 2022-10-25, you wrote:

Hi @ionixjunior thanks so much but for now the team is researching some further considerations about this

Did you come to a conclusion? Would you accept a PR that would turn the flag into a user-configurable setting?

fedemkr commented 1 year ago

Hi everyone, thanks for the additional info and initiative. We will have this ready soon in an upcoming release.

0ysoqG0O7GdnoIdaebZcMsfWhQPQ26d3remL0Eq commented 1 year ago

@fedemkr do you have an estimation for this feature? Thanks!

micahblut commented 1 year ago

@rubnogueira we have this on our backlog as something we'd like to implement, but have a few other items we're interested in tackling first.

kczssGvaUchPTpAdSdtyUvU4ZLgVCuT5pVSt16Y commented 1 year ago

This has been broken for over a year and is a real pita ... it's a simple change to re-enable (yes more work to make it a user configurable option) ... please make the change, I really don't want to have to switch to yet another password manager but its getting to the point where I may have to.

There are times when despite trusting the machine I'm on, I don't have Bitwarden installed but I still need to copy and paste a password from Bitwarden onto that client ... and at the moment I'm having to take it out of BW, into Notes, copy it from Notes and then paste it on the Desktop I'm using ... which is cumbersome.

0n7WOOrcgt4U0ls5Fh6OXXKeP5tHNPRUqHNMe9w commented 10 months ago

This has driven me NUTS thinking handoff wasn't working... PLEASE bring this back.

l71u18H3J1BhzWfVimxRGSsEUZRNOjW6EgFAVpu commented 8 months ago

Hello everyone, I've found that this feature doesn't work for some networks only. I don't know why, but I'm sure it has not been deprecated cause it's working with some wifi networks in my Mac (Sonoma 14.3.1).

0n7WOOrcgt4U0ls5Fh6OXXKeP5tHNPRUqHNMe9w commented 8 months ago

Hello everyone, I've found that this feature doesn't work for some networks only. I don't know why, but I'm sure it has not been deprecated cause it's working with some wifi networks in my Mac (Sonoma 14.3.1).

Well I wish I had your network, because on 3/3 networks of mine it doesn't work... :( Interesting find...

5qNaPEpmOv8Q1dDgQrvruXnI6K2ARY0aSCcUepR commented 8 months ago

One year ago I mentioned the work-around I was using. I've been using a work-around that's a bit easier lately:

I go into Bitwarden, edit the entry, click the "eye" to view the password and then triple-tap the password to pull up the context menu and then copy it to my clipboard using the normal iOS clipboard functionality.

Copying it in that way allows it to be pasted on my Mac. This is still six clicks instead of one, so I'd still very much like for this feature to be re-enabled.

SNK9Tz6u0by26VNQoVdY98Lg5rnfdwEq1Rv5TEA commented 5 months ago

@kstevens715 Thank you for the tip ! I'm still hoping there will be an official way to allow universal clipboard in settings, though.

aabdyli commented 3 months ago

Same issue with TOTPs. Is there any news on this?

nprime496 commented 2 months ago

+1