bjornsturmberg / NumBAT

NumBAT, the Numerical Brillouin Analysis Tool, integrates electromagnetic and acoustic mode solvers to calculate the interactions of optical and acoustic waves in waveguides.
GNU General Public License v3.0
17 stars 13 forks source link

Effective index of slot waveguides lower than expected #9

Closed thariq-shanavas closed 1 year ago

thariq-shanavas commented 1 year ago

The calculated effective index of slot waveguides using inc_shape = 'slot' is much less than expected.

For example, in Tutorial 7, the Arsenic Sulfide core (n=2.44) is sandwiched between Silicon (n=3.48) walls on a Silica substrate. The predicted effective index of the mode pictured is 1.45. The effective index predicted by COMSOL is around 1.6 The issue persists even with a finer mesh and/or different thickness of the wall.

The same issue is present in the active fork maintained by @michaeljsteel, but I am unable to open an issue there. https://github.com/michaeljsteel/NumBAT

Screenshot from 2023-02-21 16-32-06 EM_E_field_1