blue-nebula / base

Main repository of Blue Nebula, a fast-paced shooter with a unique parkour system. It is a fork of Red Eclipse and is free software.
https://blue-nebula.org
16 stars 7 forks source link

Issues with new voting dialog #229

Open TheAssassin opened 3 years ago

TheAssassin commented 3 years ago

As a long time player, I was very used to the old voting dialog. I've been using the new one for a little over four weeks now, found various issues with it. Here's a (likely incomplete) list.

I miss various features:

These issues are related to that search field being, well, a search field now. It should probably be a hybrid field: if you enter the name of a map unknown to the game, there must be an option to vote for this anyway.

Some things I find problematic:

I think the old preview system was better here, with one large thumbnail preview, and a compact list of maps. It allowed me to vote a lot faster, didn't introduce any significant lag, and was IMO easier to navigate.

I don't want to say "let's introduce the old one again". I consider the overall new UI an improvement. But I think the issues I listed need to be addressed.

metalune commented 3 years ago

I agree that these issues need to be addressed. I think putting the extra-information inside a hover-menu would be a great solution (at least for that specific issue)

metalune commented 3 years ago
metalune commented 3 years ago