Closed bauer-alex closed 1 year ago
Thanks, it's a fair point and I will improve this but this will take a while due to the number of functions. I'll put some updates here as I go along.
Hi @bauer-alex I have added a lot more unit tests and the coverage is now up over 82%. Could you have a look and see if this is sufficient for now, or if not please point to other tests to perform. One untested function you may notice is import_coin_tool() which I have left out because it would involve downloading a fairly heavy spreadsheet from the web and I worry about this causing problems with CRAN. Still, if you think this should go ahead please let me know as well. Thanks.
Seems good to me now. :+1:
Did you deliberately not test COIN_to_coin
? Seems like the only function left for which unit tests would be reasonable.
It is actually tested but requires another package to be downloaded, perhaps it is not picked up if you don't have that installed. See https://github.com/bluefoxr/COINr/blob/master/tests/testthat/test-convert.R
Indeed. I see. Alright, then I'm happy to close the issue.
Thanks and by the way improving the test coverage helped me uncover a few small bugs, so it has helped to improve the package considerably.
Issue based on the JOSS revision process (see the corresponding issue).
Based on
devtools::test_coverage()
, the unit tests in the package currently only cover 25.80% of the relevant code. This number needs to be higher to accept the paper. JOSS doesn't state a specific required test coverage and of course reaching 100% is usually not realistic (as of a lot of specific subfunctionalities when making use of individual function arguments), but currently a lot of functions have no corresponding unit tests at all. Please include unit tests for all functions of the package.