search

bluesky-social / proposals

Bluesky proposal discussions
88 stars 9 forks source link

Opt-in hashtag discoverability #8

Open davekasten opened 1 year ago

davekasten commented 1 year ago

Please consider how users who do not currently have knowledge of a hashtag could discover an opt-in hashtag, and what hiding it from non-opted-in-users by default means.

Depending (very much) on how it is implemented, there is a potential abuse vector here (again, depending on how implemented). Imagine Alice dislikes Bob. Alice creates a post with the hashtag #bobsucks and makes that an opt-in hashtag, and uses it to rally a community of Carol, Dan, etc. to engage in harassment of Bob. This potentially could limit Bob's ability to report the underlying source of other harassing posts he's receiving.

Sure, I know this is also a risk of block lists, private off-Bluesky comms channels, etc. -- but overall, given that we know dogpiling is a risk already, I'd encourage particular caution here about the fine details of implementation to mitigate further amplifying that behavioral risk.

Thanks for considering the feedback!

pfrazee commented 1 year ago

Interesting. I'm not sure I think this is a huge risk because the same thing would happen if Bob didnt follow Alice, but it's worth thinking about.