bluesky-social / social-app

The Bluesky Social application for Web, iOS, and Android
https://bsky.app
MIT License
10.35k stars 1.31k forks source link

Ability to disable the "Suggested for you" box on profile pages #5214

Open RetroSunstar opened 2 months ago

RetroSunstar commented 2 months ago

While scrolling through any profile, users will be greeted once by a "Suggested for you" box. This box contains 4 accounts suggested to the user to follow, which are the top 4 found on the Search Tab

Describe the solution you'd like

I believe this feature should have an option to disable it from appearing on profiles at all, especially on the user's own profile.

The option would be extremely nice to have for those who might not want to see it every time or at all! 🩵🩷🩵🩷

I personally would like to keep the accounts I'm suggested to follow to the Search tab, the place I'm most likely looking for accounts. Being contantly feed a list of suggestions that might be wrong and in a place I'm not expecting or wanting to see it can be a fairly negative experience

gaearon commented 2 months ago

This box contains 4 accounts suggested to the user to follow, which are the top 4 found on the Search Tab

This is not how it's supposed to work and in this case is more of a bug — it's supposed to show accounts related to the account you're viewing. There is a fallback (if it doesn't know any related accounts to the viewed account, it shows generic suggestions) but we should probably remove this fallback for this reason.

gaearon commented 2 months ago

We should probably also add a dismiss button so you can hide it. And maybe it doesn't make sense on own profile since the purpose is more about account discovery.

mschwendener commented 2 months ago

I would hide the suggestions in settings at the moment if that was an option.

But: I don't mind that they exist, I just don't like how "in my face" they are.

gaearon commented 2 months ago

Thanks everyone for feedback, we're going to take a pass:

This might take ~ a week so pls bear with us for a bit.

mschwendener commented 2 months ago

We'll make it dismissible so that you don't see it again if you don't want to

Thank you

I'm very seldom looking at twitter, but this is less intrusive to me, because it fits in the flow of my scrolling.

screenshot_5053
RossBrunton commented 2 months ago

Could you add a setting to disable these "adverts" entirely? There's already a way to discover new accounts at the top of the "Search" page, and I really don't like having algorithmically generated content in my feed.

Edit: Sorry, may have worded that a bit hotheaded there. Assuming this isn't a bug, I'd like it to be removed - I'm not interested in algorithmic content in my feed at all.

For anyone browsing this thread looking for a solution, here is a ublock origin filter to remove them:

bsky.app#?#div:-abp-has(> div > div > a[aria-label="Browse more suggestions"])