search

blunalucero / MODS-RDF

MODS RDF is an RDF ontology for MODS. As MODS is an XML schema for a bibliographic element set, MODS RDF is an expression of that element set in RDF.
7 stars 4 forks source link

relatedItem and reatedItem enumerated types #19

Closed melanieWacker closed 9 years ago

melanieWacker commented 10 years ago

Formerly on https://github.com/blunalucero/MODS-RDF/issues/9

raydAtLC commented 9 years ago

Rather than rehash the earlier discussion, which got a bit confusing, I would like to suggest a fresh approach. Let’s look at how BIBFRAME treats relationships, see http://www.loc.gov/bibframe/docs/bibframe-relationships.html . Nevermind the discussion about work to work and so on, because none of that applies to MODS. But still, there is a model there for how to indicate relationship and that model might fit here.

For example:

A MODS RDF analogy might be Where: • isPartOf is one of an enumerated set of properties in the MODSRDF namespace; • properties from external namespaces could be used instead; • if necessary a blank node can be used to indicate a relationship when there is no available property (not used in BIBFRAME).
rguenther52 commented 9 years ago

Well I was looking to modsrdf to provide the properties in a MODS to BF transformation that were lacking in BIBFRAME for relationships. There are 2: references and isReferencedBy. So if we can have properties for all those that have enumerated values for type that would be helpful-- and then apply the rest.

melanieWacker commented 9 years ago

From Working group call 10/03/2014: We will keep the properties we have defined in the current MODS/RDF but allow for addition of others not covered by MODS/RDF.